fishmanlee said:
David Prowse gets a second chance at Darth Vader:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OYaz85FrSz4&
To be completely honest, I like the "what if" scenario, I like Prowse's voice and delivery, what I find ridiculous is the laughably amateurish attitude towards dubbing that both the british and the americans seem to have. There's seldom any attempts to keep in sync WHILE recording, and honestly if you don't get it right in the booth there's little chance of making it sound convincing in post.
What they showed at 8:50 with the "Voice aligned" section was APPALLING. The music in the background can't hide flaws from attentive ears. It was very obvious that the sync had been artificially manipulated and it sounded really choppy. And that was achieved using very expensive software?? Puh-lease!
This is why the american audience comes off as having a visceral dislike for dubbing... you've always been terrible at it!
And this was ADR on only two lines, by the same actor, in a controlled studio environment with (presumably) few time constraints. I'll admit that I've seen good ADR from some english and american actors, "Star Wars" has some good examples of it, but overall... I'm not impressed at all. I know the actual intent of this video was (supposedly) to paint a picture of what it would've been like, had they chosen Prowse for the ADR on Darth Vader, but having seen and heard what good dubbing is like, if it weren't for Prowse I fail to see the point of this video. Good ADR or dubbing doesn't need expensive pieces of software to keep the sync.
Sorry for the off topic rant, but I felt it needed to be said.