Hey, it’s your edit, and if I’m the only one with an issue then I wouldn’t worry about it. It’s the ONE issue I have, and whether or not you leave it as is, I’ll still enjoy the final edit.
Very nice intro, however, I still feel the order - Opening, flashback, Harry Gets the mail, Harry has dream - Is pretty awful. Is Harry dreaming of getting the mail? The order and pacing are quite jarring, and somewhat counter-intuitive.
I assume you couldn’t fit the mail scene in somewhere else?
I cannot stress how much I love these edits, I also cannot stress how much I wish the order were different. Were you to remove the mail moment and the ten years before text, the first flashback being Harry’s dream, I feel the opening would be perfect.
My two cents.
I assume it’s best to just use some footage from Harmy’s ANH.
When I saw this image it seemed close enough to early adolescence, which is what I was thinking when I said teenage.
If I’m not mistaken TPM was originally going to feature a teenage Anakin. God, I wish it had.
I have to agree that the first grade of Threepio was excessive. I do think that the second one was a step in the right good.
I assume it’s a comparison? Before and after?
Replace the voices of all Clone Troopers, Stormtroopers, and the Fetts with that of Dee Bradley Baker.
I just saw V6, and he did add it back in.
Mio Dio, no!
I think I’ve finally realised how much I like consistent Jedi saber colours.
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1i_HFIbrUrXkei5PpZ0W17zveqlFHRxLi
But, I still prefer green blades.
Very nice as usual, Snooker!
After a few months of indecisiveness and on and off work I’ve decided to make this edit just Revenge of the Sith.
FIRST 19 MINUTES
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1Cc7qchsPJFvX6OG-AD-FpS2j_ZsfWcNj
Please tell me that the description is a Nacho Libre reference.
I gotta say, green and yellow are my preferred lightsaber colours, blue is just too vanilla for me.
However, the idea of all Jedi having the same blade colour is growing on me. It makes little sense to me for a religious organization based upon ideas of stoicism, asceticism, and the wickedness of humanity and individualism to have something of such iconographic value be so easily made different to an individual’s taste.
Then again, the same could be said for hairstyle, clothing, and hilt shape.
There are very few cases in Anjo’s edits. I can only remember there being one sex scene in this, not sure of nudity.
A) It doesn’t fit with the surrounding film
B) The effects are poor
C) The sound effects have no OOMPH
D) The choreography is both non-functional and incongruent with ANH, the Prequels, and the characters portrayed.
Not that I could do a better job, but it’s not very impressive.
Pederasty and scatological humour are right up my alley… Wait.
That bunker scene was tremendous, good work.
I find the issue not to be the video, but instead, the audio that lets it down. Though, I ain’t too keen on the video quality either.
An idea for Batman, white lenses
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1HJzuOTnnjRdshBtL4V91CnSL-jjx4IhX
Very nice.
A thought I had for Anakin’s voice would be for it to have a similar accent to JEJ’s. I really like Jones’ thespian way of speaking, his accent is American but also has a regal and educated aspect to it - not saying anything about American Accents.
Having rolled Rs and extra oration skills would, I think, make the character fit better with the OT character we all know and love.
Italiano. I’m using it for my edit, but, unlike something like the Japanese dub, the Italian dub isn’t just understandable to people who know that language. Italian is so similar to other “Romance” languages that the Spanish, Portuguese, Latin-Americans, and others can understand enough of the original dialogue for it to be a little hard to enjoy.
I grew up watching things like Batman Returns and Revenge of the Sith since before I could remember. I don’t think the stuff in TFA is enough to traumatize him, but I suppose it would still be good to be very sure as you’re watching the film that he’s okay with what’s shown.
My two cents.
Recently I returned some of my attention to the edit I started all the way back in October.
Damn, I’m productive.
Opening:
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1W_qEoJlFjxsnOhbIpH76RxxSMGMzOsEj
Mild grain and sharpening added, new colour grade, flashes added to lightsaber cuts and ignitions, among other things.
PS: Please ignore misspelling of the word “Stir”
Neither quite work for me in their current states. I’m not entirely keen on them.
Not sure how the first would be made to work, what with there being no background that would fit the spatial continuity of that scene. The second one I doubt could work simply due to the footage available.
Alas, toying around doesn’t always yield perfect clips, especially when unfinished of course.
PS, really tried to word this well. Nearly pulled a Starkiller 😛