Alexrd said:
This picture was just posted on Star Wars Facebook page, and it shows another example of the original, warmer colour timing.
Here's a quick comparison (couldn't get the exact frame):
Yes the original dose look warmer. I would say increase the yellow in this shot or adjust the White balance.
Harmy said:
Also, regarding that shot of Qui-Gon that is usually given as an example of really bad DNR in the new transfer, I don't think that's actually the case - it actually looks more like an upscale or maybe a sharpened out of focus shot - and it seems like it always was - check it out next to the shots that directly precede and follow it; BD top, HDTV bottom:
The shot seems to have much less detail compared to the neighboring shots, even in the old HDTV transfer, only there it's not as striking, because the neighboring shots aren't so detailed either and it has the dupe grain from the I.P.
I see what you mean.
Harmy said:
So, I had another chance to give the TPM BD a closer look and it isn't really that bad - both available HD transfers are bad in their own way but in direct comparison, the BD definitely wins over the HDTV/DVD master - it may have some of the grain removed but it has quite a bit of fine detail left in it and it definitely has tons more fine detail than the HDTV captures, so I think that if an HD theatrical reconstruction was to be attempted, the BD should be used as the main source.
Check this out:
Look at the detail on the tunic and Qui-Gon's hair and beard - I only have an 8GB 1080p HDTV capture of TPM, so the higher bitrate raw capture is likely better but I doubt it would make a huge difference in a low motion shot like this. I also tried adding some grain to the BD footage (3rd picture) and as you can see, it does give an illusion of more fine detail and I think it should be considered for a theatrical reconstruction using the BD as the main source.
The problem I actually find worse than the grain removal, is the color banding n the out of focus areas but there unfortunately isn't much that can be done about that.
The Blu-ray with the grain looks the best, at least there is no Edge enhancement because you sharped it.
6,082 :)
6,078 :)
Mithrandir said:
Looks like Disney has been here all througout the years...
LOL.
Nice update You_Too. Colors are superb.
adywan said:
Episode VIII: The Search For More Money
I thought that was for Spaceballs 2, lol. Sorry off-topic :(.
Father Skywalker said:
pat man said:
Over 5,744 have signed the petition. XD=:)
http://originaltrilogy.com/petition/signatures.cfm
Now Harmy has made a Facebook Group for the petition.
http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Started-a-group-on-Facebook-please-join-and-invite-your-friends/topic/11412/page/1/
http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=107395222629762
But has anyone posted it on the other socail Media sites?
If not please post on other sites.Thank you
I have an account on Twitter, and I'm am following many celebrites and famous people on there!!!!!!!
Sweet, please make a page for this and share it it would mean a lot to the fans of the Original release. Thank you if you do.
DominicCobb said:
I was going to ask why this thread was created, then I realized I actually didn't know "how to make a link numbers and letters."
So thanks pat man!
Your welcome, hope it helps.
This was from a fan on the https://www.facebook.com/swrevisited page named Ivan.
Ady, did you consider to make ESB:R a little more brighter and crisper?
For example..
http:// screenshotcomparison.com/ comparison/159801
pat man said:
Ep VII: The Return of the Empire or Rise of a New Empire.
Ep VII: The Kid of the New Jedi.
Ep IX :Fall of the New Empire.
I agree.
You guys know of the petition right?
And who as signed it?
Check this out
6,055 :)
timdiggerm said:
Yup, those images don't work here.
I see that, I'll delete it.
Some people just think different.
Davnes007 said:
This sort of thing helps everyone become a better poster, and better forum member.
True, It dose help a lot.
darth_ender said:
Oh, now I get it. You click on the chain link picture and then you can add a link. That makes sense! Shoot, what have I been missing? ;)
Yes, you got it right.
Easterhay said:
That link isn't working for me I'm afraid.
Get Google Chrome.
Please look at the Picture, thank you.
Here it shows "Send Message", but when you post a regular message, it would say "Post Reply" instead.
Thanks to Harmy, Davnes007, and Darth Tater for the help.
You guys seen this yet?
6,050 :)
