nobodybutjarjar42

omas4071 said:

pat man said:

Moiisty said:

so is this better than 4k80 or close?

4k80 is not even done yet. No idea when it’ll be released, they are taking there time and making sure everything is in order.
4K80 will be true to the Original edits of the film. D+80 uses either the Disney+ (v1.x) and UHD (v2.x)(v2.1 is the newest). D+80 is a reconstruction of the original theater version. It mainly uses the 4k 2019 masters as a source, but with the Special Editions changes replaced with 35mm film scans.

Hello everyone,

I have watched version 2.1 of this amazing edit about four times and I honestly did not notice any changes that were missed personally. The only change that was not changed back to the original theatrical version was the logo on the correct side of the imperial officer in the end, which was different from the original 1980 version.

Other than that, everything else seems to be pretty much the original theatrical version to me.

or the cropped falcon cockpit shots

first

1 last crusade
2 temple of doom
3 crystal skull
4 dial of destiny
5 raiders of the lost ark

although i find they are of similer quality

just curious which is better quality version of revisited the mp4 or the DVD9

PLEASE DELETE

the one thing that i wish ESB:R had was this C3PO line from the mono mix

daneditor said:

They’re all on MySpleen, although it’s pretty tricky to get an invite for that site these days. At least without paying for it.

accounts cannot be made on myspleen anymore

right before ROTJ got re-released in cinemas i watched ANH and ESB on the 1080p blu-ray of the 2019 cut, i watched these versions to match with the re-release

darklordoftech said:

“There’s multiple original versions”/“it’s debatable which versions are actually the originals”.

Aside fron sound mix variations and the addition of “Episode IV: A New Hope”, I’m not aware of any pre-1997 variations.

https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/List_of_changes_in_Star_Wars_re-releases#A_New_Hope
and also the elusive 70mm version of ESB

the screening i went to was the 2019 cut

just curious what the sources for 3.0 are, since i heard that the emperor hologram on adywan’s 1997 recreation is better quality then some film print scans

Ryan said:

omas4071 said:

What changes were missed in this awesome edit?

The changes that I noticed were:

• R2-D2 and C-3PO’s escape pod cover on Tatooine remained grey and was not changed back to blue.

• Darth Vader’s lightsaber stayed red when Luke blasted the door on the Death Star.

• The detention hall’s hallway remained altered with the special edition version when Luke, Leia, Han, and Chewbacca were attempting to escape.

These were the only changes that I noticed which were not restored to the theatrical version; otherwise, everything else was pretty much originally unaltered and theatrical.

I remember hearing that special edition “thud” noise from when the Storm Tropper hits his head on the blast door.

When I was checking it out on the computer and comparing it to other projects side by side, I think there are some shots that can be updated to better versions. You know the film scans used to cover up the crappy CGI.

One thing that surprised me was when Luke and Leia were in that tube where they had to swing over to get away from the Storm Troopers. Their voices were super echoey.

i thought the audio was sourced from schorman’s Star Wars LaserDisc Audio Archive and hairy_hen’s 70mm recreation

The Phantom Menace, aside from visual changes like CGI Yoda and audio changes like the removal of the “Vote now!” chanting, one of the biggest changes is that the video masters are very different. I believe the 2001 master might have more edge enhancement. The 2011 master might have been better if it wasn’t smudged to oblivion. The 2019 master adds one minor change to the podracing sequence, but it’s not something you’d notice unless you were looking for it (a visual change when Anakin was reaching out for a cable)

the podrace change was from the 3D version IIRC

WoCool said:

Can someone share with me the latest version of this? Thank you

in what way “latest version” ?

exited for the 1080p version 😃

CatBus said:

AdmiralWasabi10191 said:

Kyp_Astaar said:

I can finally rewatch Return of the Jedi without any embarassing CGI shenanigans (of which this particular movie is fuller than any other in the trilogy), i could never thank each and everyone that took part in this project enough.

May the force be with you all.

4K83 is superior. It’s a 35mm scan from film prints.

4K83 is impressive, but I personally prefer DeEd, YMMV. IMO the dividing line is between those who want a perfect recreation of the theatrical experience, versus those who are looking more for something like what a respectful Blu-ray restoration of the film to have been. Both are fine goals.

i agree, although something like D+77 D+80 and OTD83 fit that as well

Joel said:

The link is broken. Was the Rifftrax version sync’d to the WMAR broadcast? Anyway, a google search suggests that Zion Hybrid v2 is what you want.

Good luck!

i have access to Zion’s Hybrid v2, Rifftrax synced it to this google video copy and they later bundled their commentry with Zion’s Hybrid v1

this copy of the star wars holiday special is not available anymore, rifftrax used this copy for their commentry until they replaced it with a better copy, does anyone have this copy and if so could they send me a link

CourtlyHades296 said:

It has the Atmos remix, which has altered sound effects that end up making the film worse. The 4-film Batman Legacy snapcase DVD has the original 5.1 mixes for all four films.

IMO the remix is better, just personal preference, not saying it is the most definitive mix

https://www.blu-ray.com/movies/Batman-4-Film-Collection-4K-Blu-ray/272881/

Wazzles said:

This certainly jogs my memory of how blue it looked in the theaters. It never really tracked with me how different the Blu Ray looks (granted, I’ve only watched it once).

i watched the rise of skywalker twice in cinema’s

is this the best quality WCBS broadcast copy with commercials?
Star Wars Holiday Special - WCBS w/o/c “Frizzies” on myspleen

IMO yt-dlp is way better then youtube-dl, sadly does not fix that problem

i thoght of the idea to also include The Weekly Planet Commentary Track

Darth telly said:

nobodybutjarjar42 said:

Darth telly said:

Does anyone have the Rifftrax version of the special?

the rifftrax version is availible here and on youtube albeit with the very start replaced with some stock music and the cartoon is removed

can someone just send me the audio in high quality please, I dont care about the video.

btw the rifftrax release is drm free