jedimasterobiwan

buck up adywan things will work out in the end

forget a remake of the original trilogy how about a remake of the prequels to fix the flaws and make them fit with the clones wars,rebels and the original trilogy.

Dek Rollins said:

^Thanks. I might work on a little more, though, just to experiment with making the colors stronger without getting rid of the monochrome feel.

i love the work your doing. it still crushes me a tiny tiny bit your not going to make the kind of edit i would love to see for the film. 😦 but keep up the good work.

if everything works out will we see a trailer. please don’t bash me for asking

Dek Rollins said:

That’s your preference, then. I am trying to match the colors to an aproximation of the more brownish, monochrome look of the end of Evil Dead II, because I think that look really helped the scene feel other worldly, and Ash feels odd and out of place when he’s spit out in medieval England.

IMO the colors on all of the BD sources are at least slightly over-saturated, and that mixed with the generally clean look of the film, makes it feel more like a Hollywood lot, rather than feeling like medieval times. I just don’t think the original colors for the beginning sequence build atmosphere very well.

here here you did great the new version of your regrade is pretty much perfect

welp episode ix is ruined now i know carrie was the character but still 😦

i mean come on it worked in other movies why not this what excludes this what makes this untouchable give me a break

no i stand by my idea because she looks exactly like her with make up now a days they could make it work i rather episode ix finish her story the way it was intended then have episode ix feel ruined. i want leia to confront her son having her die would just suck. sorry but it would it’s bad enough han’s dead but killing her character off would be as soul crushing as carrie fisher passing away.

my idea is the best soultion have her daughter in old make up be in episode 9 as leia

DrDre said:

Darth Lucas said:

DrDre said:

I may have an opportunity to go to a private screening of a Technicolor print, so I hope that will provide some answers.

Woah woah woah! Hold up! You can’t just casually drop something like that and not provide more details!

Through the 4K77 project we came into contact with a private collector, who by chance lives reasonably close to where I live. Although he wants to remain anonymous, and is naturally very protective of his collection of films, he said might be willing to arrange a private screening of his Tech for me to help with the project’s color grading. 😃

when will we probable see the color grading results

not bad

Warbler said:

My opinion is to use CGI to have her in Episode IX and continue as previously planned with episode IX. If they were intending to kill her in episode IX, do so. If they weren’t, don’t. Some will say it would be disrespectful and it is too. It if was not disrespectful to Cushing, why would it be to Fisher? As for being too soon, just where is that line drawn? 20 years? 15 years? 10 years? 5 years? 3 years? Where??? and who decides this? I think she would want to be in episode IX. Get the approval of the fisher’s family first of course(and don’t do it without it).

better yet why not have her daughter be put in old make up boom it would be like she was still with us. much more respectful to her family if you ask me.

Dek Rollins said:

jedimasterobiwan said:

so that and the theatrical ending are the only things missing. also with the tv scene your using i think the german version has better quality if you want to find out look up ridgeshark’s abandonded edit page.

I don’t think I can use the television version for the extended windmill scene, because it’s edited differently and too much footage is missing. I’ll be using deleted scenes footage, but I still haven’t decided if the Shout! Factory BD is the best source for those or not.

jedimasterobiwan said:

Dek Rollins can you look in to doing that kinda of hybrid cut i don’t know how to do that kinda of thing and i’d do anything for that kind of edit

Sorry, I don’t think I can afford the time or space to do anything more than what I’m already trying to do. I’m sure it can be frustrating to be without good software and hardware to do this kind of stuff yourself. (I don’t even have everything that I think I might need yet 😛)

---

And an update on my editing plans:
I think I’m going to cut the idea of starting it with the end of Evil Dead II, because there doesn’t seem to be a good way to get the two scenes to mesh well, even if I was able to reduce the music in the mono. So, after the edited opening recap, the beginning of the film will continue largely identical to the Director’s Cut.

I’ve also been trying to decide whether or not to cut the “Boom Stick” speech that Ash gives to the villagers. Since neither the finished opening or the theatrical ending will be used in my edit, this line will be the only reference to S-Mart, and that seems like it might feel out of place in the long run. In that case, I would cut straight from “This is my Boom Stick!” to “The next one of you primates, even touches me…” I’m not sure about it yet, as I do like the line itself, but I just don’t think it works very well in the context I’ve created.

too bad 😦 i wish someone would add the Arthur tv scene the windmill tv whatever deleted scenes that would work. the good bad i’m the guy with the guy line,the theatrical ending using the international cut footage for parts. plus the other sources to make the ultimate cut. 😦 i don’t know where to ask for this kind of thing. 😦

Dek Rollins can you look in to doing that kinda of hybrid cut i don’t know how to do that kinda of thing and i’d do anything for that kind of edit

jedimasterobiwan said:

Dek Rollins said:

I don’t think so.

so that and the theatrical ending are the only things missing. also with the tv scene your using i think the german version has better quality if you want to find out look up ridgeshark’s abandonded edit page.

Dek Rollins said:

I don’t think so. They don’t really flow with the film in my opinion. But I think deleting the scene outside the windmill was a great loss to the pacing and tone of the scene, not to mention that it properly explains the scene that comes after, so I decided to include that.

what about the tv scene in the beginning with ash and arthur?

Dek Rollins said:

Okay, I may use the International Cut as a main source, but I might just go with the Director’s Cut for the majority of the film since that’s the cut I’m basing my edit on. It would just make it easier. But I really haven’t decided yet.

And like I said, I also haven’t decided on what I will use for the reinserted scene. I could use the TV cut, but I might end up using the version from the “Deleted Scenes.”

Are you using any other deleted scenes like the henry the red scene etc?

Dek Rollins said:

I said in the first post that I will be using “Good, bad, I’m the guy with the gun.” I’m not sure what you mean by “4k mastered footage.” My main video sources will be the three different cuts from the ShoutFactory! Blu-ray set.

well the international cut is 4k mastered and the tv cut has two extra scenes to me this combined with the theatrical on the director’s cut is the definitive version it lines up with the tv series

adywan said:

TV’s Frink said:

adywan said:

jedimasterobiwan said:

sorry but why the silence?

Because i like making you suffer

I laughed, but then I read his last post, and I think you aren’t making him suffer enough.

Well i was going to release ESB:R next month, but i think i will leave that until 2020 just to make him suffer more after his comment 😉

What did i do sheesh

Dek Rollins said:

I’m not sure yet if I’ll be using the TV cut as a source. I’m not planning on using the theatrical opening or the theatrical ending. All of the info on my current plans for the edit is in the first post.

what about good bad i’m the guy with the gun line and the 4k mastered footage are you going to use that?

Kaweebo said:

Sorry this is the wrong thread, idk where else to put this question. For your Prequel edits, are you going to have Anakin come with the Jedi to Naboo towards the end of TPM? I always thought it was really dumb how they brought him into a warzone.

what the clone wars the lost missions they are flat out retarded in that

adywan said:

Because i like making you suffer

oh ha ha

will you be combining the director’s cut from the shout blu ray with the two tv scenes and the theatrical ending and using the 4k mastered footage mixed with the tv and director’s cut and with the line good bad i’m the guy with the gun?

sorry but why the silence?

this is dead isn’t it 😦