QUESTION: Is the list of fixes on the first page up to date?
Man, I just noticed that it's been over 2 years since this thread was first made. It doesn't seem that long at all.
vaderios said:
Coming back around still even ady posted previous shots that indicating the falcon arrives at sunset still like the idea of sunrise :)
-Angel
I agree. Sunrise would look so much better!
I've never actually noticed any of the flipped shots before. But if they are flipped, they should be un-flipped.
Bingowings said:
Must not give George ideas....
shanerjedi said:
THRAWN!!!!!
Make Episode 7 now! Have Thrawn escape at end of 6 and make him main villain of 7!
Yes!!!!!!!!
That would actually be awesome.
I also like the Illusive Man concept. Uneeded, but it has my vote.
vaderios said:
-Angel
That looks amazing! I hope something like this actually gets into the edit.
rcb said:
darthmunky said:
His skin actually looks real in ROTJ. In ROTS, it looks like he's wearing a rubber mask and has 2 yellow pennies in his eyes.
that was his actual face, not the eyes, there was just a lot of make up involved.
Yeah, I know. Which is why I just don't understand how it can look so fake.
I'm just wondering; has anyone been keeping tabs on all the suggestions we've made in this thread so when Ady actually gets to the PT, he won't have to look through this entire thing?
His skin actually looks real in ROTJ. In ROTS, it looks like he's wearing a rubber mask and has 2 yellow pennies in his eyes.
vaderios said:
Something ive noticed navigating through the menus.
Vader in the menus is taller and his stance is more straight.
Plus there is a better definition of forms and detail between the stair section.
Who is the more aggressive?
I prefer his stance in the bottom picture, looks way more menacing.
Anakin is not going to look like Hayden for the simple reason that Vader died as an old(er) man, not as a young Hayden. Look at Yoda and Ben; they are not their younger selves, but as they were when they died
Yes, but apparently when Anakin turned to the dark side, he became Darth Vader and Anakin died. Obi-Wan and Yoda even said that.
I think the only lightsaber colors in the entire saga should be blue, green, and red. I think Yoda, Windu, Dooku, and Luke should be the only ones with green.
That is awesome! Looks good, I'd be happy with that although I'd still prefer an alternative. I don't want him to look like Shaw but I don't think he should look the same as he did in RotS either. I'm still voting for the morph. Also, I think his clothes should be replaced with his dark tunic from the PT.
Okay, I have a suggestion that will 96% not be considered for this edit and a lot of people will hate it but.... The cave scene, I'd be okay with it cut from the film and just having it on the dvd as a deleted scene. Watching the new Star Wars Family Guy made me realize how unneeded and confusing it really is.
Shouldn't TPM CG Yoda look 10 years younger than the AOTC Yoda?
Well, is a new version of TPM coming out soon with the new Yoda? What if it's not out by the time Ady starts work on the prequels?
I think Phantom Menace is the worst title ever... No one is a phantom... Menace is a stupid word. I'd like it if the Episode 2 was called the clone wars, and Revenge of the Sith is my 2nd favorite title out of the whole saga (Empire being my #1 favorite)
I've also been thinking about titles, has Adywan mentioned anything about renaming any of the prequels?
I don't think he will, since I'm guessing he will just add Revisited to the title. He can't say Fall of the Jedi Revisited. Although, I would love to see AOTC renamed.
Oh yeah, I never thought of that.
As for the AotC title debate, I like that it's classic cheesy but I don't like that it says the clones are attacking. Usually when titles are 'Attack of', it refers to something attacking the good guys. And the reason I don't like phantom menace as a title is because it's so different from the rest of the saga's titles.
I've been thinking about lightsabers in the prequels lately. Dooku wasn't really a legitimate Sith was he? So shouldn't he have a blue or green saber? (I think it should be green so when he fights Anakin, we see a rare green vs blue) Not seeing a red lightsaber in AotC would be cool because it would put even more emphasis into the title of RotS. And in RotS, I think Anakin should have red lightsaber at the end, revealing it when he turns it on to kill the younglings.
I've also been thinking about titles, has Adywan mentioned anything about renaming any of the prequels? I always thought Phantom Menace was a terrible title since it was first announced and Attack of the Clones is misleading. I really like Revenge of the Sith and if it had to be changed, the only ones I'd agree with are "Rise of the Empire", "Fall of the Jedi", or "Return of the Sith"
My friend suggested this, says it goes well as a saga:
The First Hope
The Republic Strikes Back
Return of the Sith
A New Hope
The Empire Strikes Back
Return of the Jedi
That looks TERRIBLE!!!
I’m trying to find the version of RoTS that has Chinese subtitles directly translated to English. Anyone know where I can get it?
vaderios said:
AWESOME! Is it even possible to recreate a shot like that?
I'm watching ROTJ right now and I have come to the conclusion that the entire musical/dance number at Jabba's Palace should be completely removed. Although one might argue that it would cause continuity problems for when it shows the dancer try to choke Jabba and fall into the Rancor pitt. Well, that can be cut too. That way, when Luke falls down, the audience will be like "Holy crap, secret trap door!"
Another thing, this has got to be one of the worst scale problems I have ever seen in a Star Wars movie:
Shot 1 - Showing the Banthas
Shot 2 - Showing the Banthas from far away?
Then the shot pans to the left to reveal the Sail Barge, does this seem wrong to you? It makes the Banthas look like they're mice...
vaderios said:
facebook will be the death of me :(
-Angel
Why don't you just get Facebook? It's not a hassle at all.
I like those mockups Vaderios, but what about having it even earlier in the morning?
