I would not have a problem showing my kids(if I had them) an original VHS tape of the OUT even here and now in 2014.
An entire generation grew up watching them on VHS(or Beta,V2000 ,laserdisc or TV broadcasts) without it hindering their love of the story,characters or it's special effects.
Check out this review from the net.movies usergroups in jan 85' shortly after ESB was released( the person owns a Betamax---at the time considered to be slightly better than VHS)
19/01/1985
My own findings with the rental films have been
as follows (and I realize that there are bound to be
variances from copy to copy):
(1) Empire Strikes Back - I rented this primarily for my
4-year-old, but thoroughly enjoyed it. In terms of
picture quality and exploitation of the HiFi sound-
track this has been the best pre-recorded videotape
I've encountered. I know that many sf-lovers found
this a disappointing stopping point between the
more spectacular "Star Wars" and "Return of the Jedi"
but I found the characters more touching and absorbing
than I had expected.
https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/net.movies/euqD0hWQabc
Now even back then we all knew that the optimum way to experience these films was in a theater.
Personally speaking, my love for these films was created in a theater(watching SW and ESB back to back in 81')........but that love was solidified by watching them on my V2000(early competitor to VHS) throughout the early 80's.
Many others never had the opportunity to watch them in a cinema but still fell in love with them through home video.
And here in lies the rub.
These films(and I am refering explicitly to the OUT) were not meant to be watched over and over again.
Lucas even says so in the commentary track for the 2004 DVD
"You were meant to see it once and be blown away"
Now ofcourse, many did go back to the cinema to watch these flicks again and again during their original theatrical runs but you can't pause a 35mm print during a screening......you cant rewind or fast forward or watch it in slow motion.Those benefits are only the virtue of home video.
I am assuming you also saw them in the cinema at the time of the original releases but be honest Msycamore, do you honestly remember every precise detail of the story(or how good the picture quality was frame by frame) from those theatrical screenings.
Of course you don't(no one does).
You only know these films back to front(like me) because you have watched them far too many times on whatever home video format you have had the priviledge of owning.
You will NEVER EVER be able to enjoy these films as much those original cinema screenings simply because you have been over exposed to them.
It does not matter if the OUT is released on Blu Ray or 4K............you will never be satisfied due to viewing oversaturation spanning 3 decades.
So you channel your anger at Lucas' s unwillingness to release the OUT or the changes he has made(both cosmetic and story wise)to the "special edition".
You very immaturely call a video technician who worked on the 2004 DVDs ,Vidiot(of the SteveHoffman forum) an Idiot for straying too far from the original colour pallete despite THE FACT you have absolutely no clue as to what the original colour pallete is.
Sure....you own a few transperencies(35mm or 70mm) and you have seen a few screen shots of the senator theater showing in 2010 ...... but that does not give you the authority(or anyone-else on this forum) of having a say in exactly how these film looked originally.....when the FACT of the matter is that the quality of resolution and colour reproduction of any theatrical viewing of SW in the late 70's or early 80's would have varied from cinema to cinema and from print to print(be it 35mm or 70mm) .
It is one of the main reasons why 35mm is being phased out in favour of digital (2K or 4K both of which have been scientifically proven to be better than 35mm projection).
Now having said all that I still want to see a release of the OUT on Blu Ray as much as anyone-else here.
In the meantime the 2011 BluRay(upscaled to 4K in my case) or the original VHS will suffice.
I dont complain that I cant see the original theatrical edits of classics such as Das Boot or Amadeus on blu Ray.
I suggest that you do the same for Star Wars.
And if you cant enjoy it(any version on any format) then dont watch it.
You have clearly watched it too many times already.