canadianbs101

Could I please have a PM Harmy? Thanks!

Those clips are fantastic! I can't believe it took me until now to find out about all of these preservation efforts. I've been making due with the official releases for years.

Sorry, I have zero editing/authoring knowledge (I'm more of a consumer unfortunately). I hope you get it figured out, and we appreciate your hard work on this project!

ibleedspeed said:

 i think the problem was mostly that i could not find his dual layer release.

I have the DL release, and unfortunately it still isn't that good.

i am still working and considering the best ways to bring the quality up to my expectations.its hard to judge between video quality and special features.

IMHO, I'd say tip the scales away from special features, since to download your fanedit we should own the official releases with all of their bonus features already (unless you're planning new ones of course).

Sounds great! I recently found the QtheGaijin edit but was disappointed by the dead surround channels and the video quality, but appreciated having the extended O-Ren sequence and being able to watch the film in one shot. Looking forward to checking out your edit!

Can't wait!

As much as I'd love to test these, I don't think I have enough knowledge to bring anything constructive to the table. I'm looking forward to the final results Harmy!

Sounds like this is progressing really quickly. Looking forward to it Harmy!

Got em now. Thanks guys! (and thanks to ChainsawAsh for building them; I grew up with these)

I was at work when I saw that these were re-discovered and couldn't download, and now that I'm home the download limit of 10 has hit. Can you please re-upload?

You, sir, are my hero of the day!

Very cool. Thanks guys!

Jetrell Fo said:

I do want mention, yet again, that the artwork for these is very frickin cool.

 Would it be possible to post some pics/links of the artwork? You've piqued my interest :)

All three clips look great!

Colour me excited!

I didn't watch it all the way through but watched at least a minute at each chapter stop. It seemed fine to me, although I definitely have untrained eyes and ears, so I'm sure hairy_hen's assessment is much more accurate than mine :)

Moth3r said:

hairy_hen said:

So adywan's ESB recreation is completely gout-synched?  Awesome.  I haven't had a chance to see his version yet (sacrilege, I know!), but I'll have to do that soon.  If this mix will fit to it that would make it even better for me.

I remember reading that his version is GOUT-synched -  although it may require a different initial delay, this shouldn't present a problem.

I'm not sure if anyone has tried this yet, but I just synched hairy_hen's ESB 5.1 "Purist" mix to Adywan's ESB reconstruction with no problems (thanks to Erikstormtrooper and Chewtobacca for their help).

Chewtobacca, have you tried swapping hairy_hen's ESB 5.1 "purist" track into Adywan's ESB Reconstruction? I remember reading elsewhere that an initial audio delay may be needed for a proper synch. (Sorry if I'm getting off-topic).

Thanks to both of you! I'll let you know how it turns out.

UPDATE: Success! Thanks again.

Erikstormtrooper, would you be willing to share a copy of your DVD-5 tweak? I've been thinking of doing the same thing, but am oblivious as to how to do it. If not, a PM of Chewtobacca's instructions would be most appreciated (please!)

Thank YOU. I feel like a freeloader around here, reaping the benefits of your guys' hard work :)

I got them back early, so here's a look at your handywork Harmy. I had to move the Fox Logo and the PDE banner down a little as the covers were printing out a little too tall (although that was most likely a problem on my end; I don't have the best setup or software). Also, forgive my poor photography skills!

Erikstormtrooper said:

More detailed instructions would be great. I've never done this before.

Chewtobacca, could you please PM me these instructions as well? Thanks!

Harmy said:

@canadianbs101: I'm glad you liked them. I must say, I didn't burn them yet, so I still don't have the covers printed out, could you post some pictures? I'd like to see what they look like as an actual set :-)

Sure thing! It won't be till later in the week as I've lent them to my brother.

I just finished watching the PDE trilogy for the first time, and I loved it! They're now displayed proudly on my shelf with your custom cover designs. Thanks again for the links and the hard work Harmy.