logo Sign In

bkev

User Group
Members
Join date
10-Mar-2007
Last activity
21-Sep-2024
Posts
5,293

Post History

Post
#463683
Topic
Let JediTray back in
Time

Frink, I think skyjedi deserves a bit of a real explanation.

Skyjedi,a as I gather Jeditray got a bit of constructive criticism and deleted his threads. He then got annoyed that he didn't get some DVDs he wanted and started bagging on the entire community. He then canceled his project numerous times. He also has apparently harassed Adywan behind the scenes, which appears to be in-character. However, JediTray is not a part of the problem that this is a members-only club; although I would say that's a bit of an issue. That's bound to happen at any forum, though...

Post
#463600
Topic
Random Thoughts
Time

Dear Westboro Baptist Church:
Protesting military funerals is one thing. But planning to protest the funeral of the innocent child who died during the recent Arizona shooting, Christina Green, is beyond appalling. I rarely say this seriously, but burn in hell. Suffer. Seriously. The poor 9 year old only wanted to meet her congresswoman.

I swear, I'm almost crying. A bit watery-eyed, but no tears.

(note: they traded this in for airtime on the Mike Gallagher Radio Show, who gave it to them for the specific purpose of making it so that they would not in fact protest.

Post
#463229
Topic
Shrinking Star Wars?
Time

Hi everybody,
I'm not really much for long posts so I'll try and make this brief. Anchorhead once said that Lucas shrank the Star Wars universe by connecting characters together when they didn't need to be - for example, did Lando really need to own the Falcon before Han? Not really. I've been thinking about this, and he really has a point. Most of my examples will be PT ones, but just to start off:

-Anakin building 3PO. Unneeded connection.

-Count Dooku being Qui-Gon's master. Sure, it's a nice reminder that the only interesting character from the previous movie is gone, but is it needed? Certainly not. He could/should have been any regular old rogue Jedi.

-Anakin being raised on Tatooine. Perhaps not so bad, but he could have been found ANYWHERE in the vast Star Wars universe. He was there no reason other than Lucas's "poetry in motion" and the fact that it was already a popular, well-established locale that people would enjoy revisiting.

-Luke and Leia being siblings. The quality of the plot device is debatable, but there's no doubt that it shrank the universe. Characters that were once from completely different worlds basically came from the same one, even if they didn't get raised in it.

I'm sure there are more examples, but I'm a little tired and this is all I got tonight. Any other thoughts? Disagreements?

Post
#461991
Topic
RedLetterMedia's Revenge of Nadine [TPM 108 pg Resp. [RotS Review+RotS Preview+ST'09 Reveiw+Next Review Teaser+2002 Interview+AotC OutTakes+Noooooo! Doc.+SW Examiner Rebuttal+AotC Review+TPM Review]
Time

Qui-Gon is definitely my favorite prequel-only character. It's such a shame he was so under-utilized, Liam Neeson is a fantastic actor. And, in the EU, Qui-Gon's a badass. It's a shame it was up to the EU to flesh out what could have been a great character in the movies themselves; that really shouldn't happen.