- Post
- #1662822
- Topic
- The Best Fan Edits Ever?
- Link
- https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1662822/action/topic#1662822
- Time
i have never been on fanedit org
i have never been on fanedit org
Wicketthewarrick, honest question, how old are you?
i wasn´t trolling i was serious
even though i talk about the original versions of the og trilogy i to like the special editions but i take the original versions as the canon versions and i consider episodes 1,2 and episode 3 fanedits of padme living at the end of rots as canon and i consider the canon events of the clone wars to be diferent events from both multimedia projects but i still consider canon anakin meeting red leader during the clone wars and the battle of alderaan and the reason for that is because if i consider fanedits of padme living canon than none of the multimedia projects fit since they are both canon with rots theatrical release and despite considering the original versions to be canon i still think that lucas should have replaced anakin jedi robes that he has at the end of rotj with the clotches he was wearing on mustafar with is the same clotches he was wearing in the ashoka show because it made more sense for him as a force ghost to wear those instead of the jedi robes
lucas should have replaced puppet jabba and puppet yoda with cgi jabba and cgi yoda because it looks strange young kids seeing how yoda looks like in esb and rotj compared to the prequels and also looks strange kids seeing jabba in rotj after seeing him in a new hope and see how diferent he looks compared to how he is in rotj and if lucas didn´t do that because of the haters he should have not care that they would attack him and do that.a director should not listen to tooxic people with is why he shouldn´t have given jar jar a minor role because of those people specially since even after lucas did that nothing change those pieces of trash still attack him because of jar jar not to mentioned that is a stupid thing to criticize since he was made for the kids but this people think that star wars was allways for adults only
how could you got it wrong everything i said?
I didn’t get it wrong. When you find it, show me and I’ll admit that I’m wrong.
what you mean?i was talking about my comment
to match how jabba looks like in the later releases not how he looks like in 97
when i said the vhs versions i didn´t meant looking like the same quality i meant the changes that the vhs releases did in those films like c3po talking instead of being silence in the scene where it shows in the monitor where it is the tractor beam
mikebailey15 said:
give me tcw fanedit with matt being dubbed by hayden
i would like a fanedit of the original versions of the original trilogy and i mean the versions that were released on vhs and aired on tv not the theatricall versions that restores deleted scenes and replaced puppet yoda and puppet jabba with AI jabba and AI yoda and i wish lucas did replaced puppet yoda and puppet jabba from rotj with cgi yoda and cgi jabba and made cgi jabba in rotj look like how he looks like in a new hope because it looks weird for younger fans who watches the movies seeing how different yoda looks like in the original trilogy and how diferent jabba looks like in rotj after seeing him in a new hope and of course i want that fanedit to do what adywan´s did with the emperor look in his esb fanedit
i would have liked if somebody did a clone wars series that its canon with the six movies but its not canon with both clone wars multimedia projects and in the canon of that clone wars tv series padme survived revenge of the sith and took baby leia to alderaan and die between episodes 3 and 4 because in my canon the prequels happened but padme survives the events of rots and dies from sadness between episodes 3 and 4 when luke and leia are 4 year olds just like in the rotj novel with is why i would like if somebody did that clone wars tv series because if in my canon padme lives at the end of episode 3 than i cannot obviously take neither one or the other clone wars multimedia project as canon since both are canon with rots theatrical release with is why i would like if somebody did that series so i have a clone wars series to watch between episode 2 and episode 3 padme lives fanedit and i can watch clone wars 2d or tcw when im not doing my canon marathon and looking at those shows when im watching them as in universe holodramas
i want this to be a droid reboot the droids cartoon and c3po and r2 being accidentally separated from antillies between 3 and 4 and having diferent masters while they were separated from antillies should be canonized but if lucasfilm doesn´t put the st in a alternate timeline than its indiferent to me if droids and them being accidentelly separated from antillies is canonized or not because i don´t want the droids cartoon in the same canon as the sequels i want the st to be rebooted based on lucas sequels i want droids cartoon to be canon with the six movies and lucas sequels with darth maul and darth talon
and if nobody does it i accept that
i was not demanding i was asking
MK 9000 it doesn´t have to be you doing it somebody else that also read my fanedit idea could choose to do it but im not saying i don´t want you to do it anymore im saying it doesn´t have to be you
don´t know why anybody yet ever did those fanedits before
obi-wan haters don´t understand the lore and don´t know what they are talking about when they criticize the show obi-wan knew anakin was vader but didn´t knew he was alive but the haters think the scene is about him finding out that anakin is now called vader and i hate how the toxic haters attack leia and the actress she is what a 10 year old leia is supposed to be and the actress did a good job and nitpicking about the scene where she is running from his captors and criticizing her sinze is stupid there are 10 year olds that have her size they are not all more taller than the actress they made the right choice in choosing that actress
the mandalorian is great its not mediocre its like lucas star wars and obi-wan is a great show its not unwatchable and you are wrong in thinking george hates the mandalorian and the kenobi show why would he?its like his star wars you don´t understand what star wars is supposed to be and you think george hates what you hate if you understood what star wars is supposed to be you would love the mandalorian people like you that call the mandalorian mediocre are idiots and grogu is someting that george would create you are the same people that think that andor is a masterpiece with shows that you people don´t understand star wars and i know lucas hates andor because its bad both the st andor and the acolyte should be put in a alternate timeline and rebooted and resistence is bad to because its canon with the st but the other shows are good
what are you talking about?nobody call you toxic or a hater
does that mean you want to do it?
so what?you are not gonna do my fanedit idea just because its a lot of i wants?
I want a fanedit of the Star Wars Prequels that restores deleted scenes and includes Plagueis in Episode 1 and also his death.I don´t want the book or the entire Legends timeline to be 100% canon with those fanedits,I only consider parts of the Plagueis book as canon like Plagueis dying the night before he was elected chancellor and I don´t consider canon any reference to SW:TOR or Vitiate in that book.I don´t want any scenes from the Skywalker Stories YT channel that reference SW:TOR stuff to be included.
I want some parts of the book to be canon with those fanedits, but not the entire book, or the entire Legends timeline. I was interested in faneditor Womp Rat’s Prequel edits, until i noticed that his fanedits seem to take legends as 100% canon. In his Episode 2 fanedit, he included that Skywalker Stories scene where Plagueis talks to Palpatine about Sith history, and that scene has references to SW:TOR stuff. Also in his Episode 1 edit, he didn´t even include Plagueis death and that was weird.
I want Padme to survive in the Episode 3 edit, but I don´t want anakin causing damaged on her when he force chock her to be the reason of the cause of her death between episodes 3 and 4 like in hal9000’s fanedit. I want the medical droid to just say that she is completelly healthy, and Luke and Leia are born at that time, because its time for them to be born, instead of they were born because they had to make an operation to save the babies, so Luke and Leia in the canon of those fanedits were conceived a little earlier than they were in legends or canon.
I want AI to be used to have Padme on Alderaan holding Leia and crying. We can assume that Padme dies when Leia was very young from sadness, because she was separated from Luke and because her husband turned to the dark side, and because of how the state of the galaxy was, and because she could not do anything about that because she had to stay hidden, and because her husband choked her, because even if it didn´t do any damage on her him choking her would still have broken her heart.
im looking for a episode 1 fanedit that has plagueis besides the womp rat edit can somebody tell me other episode 1 fanedits that has plagueis in it?i also looking for a episode 3 fanedit that has padme surviving episode 3 besides hal9000 and Q2 fanedits i know there is the cutter episode 3 fanedit that has padme surviving episode 3 can somebody tell me if the cutter edit can be found?and besides the cutter fanedit is there other episode 3 fanedits that has padme surviving?
george rules and the haters are wrong about what they say about him and don´t know anything about filming or at least they don´t know more than george
ewoks rule
both ewoks movies are good.facts