logo Sign In

Warbler

This user has been banned.

User Group
Banned Members
Join date
7-May-2003
Last activity
28-May-2021
Posts
18,708

Post History

Post
#107182
Topic
Rankings
Link
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/107182/action/topic#107182
Time
Originally posted by: Bossk
I just hope he didn't come back for a couple of posts and then will disappear again. If so, I'm declaring a road trip.

Motti, explanation please.


You would do a road trip on Motti?!?

With all due respects TMB, I don't think even you have that kind of authority. I think only Dayv could order a road trip against Motti. But we'll have to ask Gundark on this, he's the legal expert.
Post
#107175
Topic
How do you rate EpIII?
Link
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/107175/action/topic#107175
Time
I just want to make one thing clear my boycotting EpIII has nothing to do with the quility of that movie. If you said it was the worst movie ever and Lucas had put the OOT on DVD, I would go see EpIII asap. But the OOT is not on DVD so even if you all say it was the best movie of all time I won't go watch.


Bossk, I am really suprised that you would put Attack Of The Clowns above Jedi. You perfer the crappy cgi Yoda/Duku battle to the climatic battle between Luke and Vader? You think the Ewoks are worse than JarJar? Are any of the scenes in AOTC anywhere near to the umasking of Vader scene or when Vader turns back to the good of the force? You like the line where Anakin compares Padme's skin to sand better than "Let me look on you with my owns eyes"? You think the acting was better in AOTC than Jedi? You complain about how unbelievable it is that the Ewoks defeated the Empire . But they didn't, they HELPED take over a shield generator. They did not do it alone, they had Han, Leia, Chewy,R2D2,3PO, and the rest of the rebel assault team(remember the assault team was put together with intent that they would take the generator alone). Also the Ewoks had the home field advantage. Please also remember this was before Lucas came up the stupid idea of making the stormtroopers clones of Fett, before in the OT the Stormtrooper were not that great of soldiers. With all this in mind, I find it very believable that the Rebels and Ewoks could take and blow up the Shield Generator. Now, I am not going to disagree with your placement of ROTS over Jedi cause without having seen it, for all I know you are correct. But putting Attack of the Clowns over an OT movie? With all due respect, please rethink this my friend.

here is my ranking of the five movies I have seen:
(from Best to Worst
1 Star Wars
2 The Empire Strikes Back
3 Return Of The Jedi
4 The Fake Menace
5 Attack Of The Clowns