logo Sign In

Warbler

This user has been banned.

User Group
Banned Members
Join date
7-May-2003
Last activity
28-May-2021
Posts
18,708

Post History

Post
#229629
Topic
Please tell me I'm not the only one....
Time
Originally posted by: Yoda Is Your Father

So was being wheelchair-bound what got him taken off the Enterprise? .

"The Menagerie" never makes clear how his command of the Enterprise ended nor is it clear if was still the Captain of the Enterprise at the time of the accident.


Originally posted by: Darth Simon


if im not mistaken, that episode was actually the original pilot episode (well the story told in it was) it was one of those 'flashback' episodes, i believe they used a trial if my memory serves me correctly. they showed clips of the mission with captain pike's crew (the clips were from the original pilot)

the only character that survived the original pilot was Spock. They felt that the audience wouldnt buy the 2nd in command being female (it was actually gene rodenbury's wife). not sure if there was any other reason they scrapped that pilot or not.

*edit* just went back and read the whole thread and noticed that HSvIIJ mentioned the pilot episode. i couldnt quite remember the title of it but HSvIIJ mentioned it in his post 'The Cage'

-Darth Simon

you are correct The first pilot was "The Cage" Pike was the Captain of the Enterprise in it, Spock was in it as well. The 2nd in command on Pike's ship was Roddenberry's wife She would go on to play Nurse Chapel in TOS and Troy's mother in Nextgen. The Cage was never aired, the Network execs didn't think Trek was good enough. But, they let Roddenberry film another Pilot(imagine what the Sci-Fi world would be like he had been unable to film the 2nd Pilot). The 2nd pilot is the Episode "Where No Man Has Gone Before" it had Kirk in command, it aired and thus TOS was started. Scenes from "The Cage" were used the TOS episode "The Menagerie", thus making "The Cage" and Pike part of the Offical Canon.
Originally posted by: Mike O


Oh boy; Trek talk! This should be interesting. Geek time! Just kidding. Hasn't Jeffery Hunter passed away?


1. discussing Star Wars isn't Geeky?
2. Yes Jeffery Hunter is dead.

Originally posted by: Mike O

I take it you don't care much for post-Kirk Trek?


Post-Kirk isn't the problem. Post-Nextgen series and Post-Roddenberry is what the problem is.
Post
#229114
Topic
Please tell me I'm not the only one....
Time
You can't kill him off because Pike was in an Episode of TOS called "The Menagerie", he was clearly never demoted, although seriously injured in some sort of accident where he sacrificed himself to save others he was paralized and stuck to a wheel chair. To kill Pike off would create a big plot inconstancy. If they tried to do with Trek what they doing with Superman (i.e. forgetting some of the episodes or movies) I will refused to see such movie.