logo Sign In

Superweapon VII

User Group
Members
Join date
30-May-2022
Last activity
5-Sep-2025
Posts
897

Post History

Post
#1545746
Topic
Unpopular Opinion Thread
Time

Spartacus01 said:

If the Force did not exist, the inhabitants of the Star Wars Galaxy would have experienced not even half of the wars they experienced through Galactic history. The Force is the real problem of the Star Wars Galaxy. The more I look at the Saga, and the more I realize that this is the case. If Kreia had managed to extinguish the Force and make everyone insensitive to the Force, then the Star Wars Galaxy would have been much better for the next millennia. Sure, some of my favorite characters would never have been born, but it would have been worth it

I’d say unsubtle creators who treat the Force like superpowers and Force users like superheroes/villains are the real problem.

Post
#1545554
Topic
The Unpopular Film, TV, Music, Art, Books, Comics, Games, & Technology Opinion Thread (for all you contrarians!)
Time

I just watched Moontrap (1989) for the first time. This movie’s apparently regarded lowly, but I quite liked it. The ending was executed a bit weakly, but I still felt it was was well-made overall. How wrong can you go with Walter Koenig and Bruce Campbell as the leads?

Post
#1543575
Topic
The Random <em>Star Wars</em> Pics &amp; GIFs Thread
Time

Sideburns of BoShek said:

I kinda like the second one, actually. At that point in time, Luke was still dangerously close to falling to the dark side. Yoda would’ve been smart enough to realize it’d be a faux pas if he tipped Luke off about those 50-100 Jedi, only for Luke to join the Empire and go on a little Jedi hunt afterward.

Post
#1543166
Topic
The Clone Wars messes up continuity or how Lucas is still destroying star wars.
Time

Humby said:

Superweapon VII said:

Darth Tremor said:

The issue is Ahsoka. I like her, but Vader’s line, “when I left you I was a learner, now I am the Master,” indicates Vader was never a Jedi Master as Anakin.

Or a full knight for that matter. Just another bit of OT continuity Lucas either forgot or ignored when writing the prequels.

I’ve always been of the mindset that we fans can often take dialogue too literally. This is a case of that for me. After 20 years of experience, a medical doctor would certainly acknowledge that they were still a learner in their first few years out of med school, even though they may still hold the same title. The line is just meant to establish the dynamic of the characters in the scene, it’s not meant to be expository.

To make the case for this particular topic, you’d be better off using Obi-Wan’s line to Luke that Vader “was a pupil of mine until he turned to evil.” Because that IS meant to be expository. But for me personally, even that is vague enough to allow for some wiggle room, as many young (and even older) professionals in the real world have pupil/mentor relationships with others in their field who simply have more experience.

I think we often need to give character dialogue the freedom of having been generalized, abbreviated, obfuscated, etc… because that’s just how humans communicate. We use shorthand, we leave out unnecessary details, we avoid painful discussions. And it doesn’t always paint an accurate picture of our experiences. Just my 2 cents.

I actually agree that fans tend to take dialogue (and text crawls, for that matter) too literally. I’ll just balance that with an observation of my own: fans who like the prequels often refuse to hold Lucas to the same standards they hold any other SW creator to. If Filoni contradicts the Clone Wars multimedia project, it’s a great sin. But if Lucas contradicts the EU, or the OT novelizations, or the OT itself, in roll the appeals to ad hoc retcons, headcanon, and George’s Vision™. After so many years of this crap, I’m at the end of my rope with it.

Post
#1543079
Topic
The Clone Wars messes up continuity or how Lucas is still destroying star wars.
Time

Darth Tremor said:

The issue is Ahsoka. I like her, but Vader’s line, “when I left you I was a learner, now I am the Master,” indicates Vader was never a Jedi Master as Anakin.

Or a full knight for that matter. Just another bit of OT continuity Lucas either forgot or ignored when writing the prequels.

Post
#1543078
Topic
Things that make you realise you're getting older
Time

Spuffure said:

Superweapon VII said:

Fernand said:

Going on youtube and seeing what crap comes up.

That reminds me. Mr. Beast has such a slappable face.

Same. I liked his old content better. Remember “Worst Intros”?

Never watched a single one of his videos. I only know him from the thumbnails YouTube persistently shoves in my face when I’m not signed in.

Post
#1541845
Topic
Great movies you hate.
Time

FYI, if you can’t appreciate Surrealist filmmaking, you’re not going to be able to appreciate more than a handful of Lynch’s films. A Straight Story, The Elephant Man, and Blue Velvet are his most accessible, general audience-friendly films.

While I love Lynch, Mulholland Drive has always left me cold. It started life as a pilot for a TV series until plans for the series fell through, leaving Lynch to reconfigure it into a feature film, and I think it shows, with subplots that you could imagine gradually unfolding across multiple episodes just going nowhere in the final product.