logo Sign In

Shimraa

User Group
Members
Join date
24-Jul-2003
Last activity
1-Aug-2007
Posts
6,563

Post History

Post
#124709
Topic
Harry Potter *Spoilers* (Serious Discussions Only, No Flaming)
Link
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/124709/action/topic#124709
Time
yeah i accidentally read the first line of chalts post on teh first page, so i knew dumbledore was going to die. But i guessed at some point he had to die, i always figured it was going to be in the last book.

but as for my theory with snape, i dont think it was part of dumbledores plan to have him continue to work with the order. I think snape was going to become a lone ranger in the Death eaters, cause it would be way to dangerous for him to still be in contact with the order even when it was him who killed dumbledore, it would be too suspisous. so the plan would be that snape was working alone. he wouldnt have informed the order so as to keep the illusion. now that snaped killed dumbledore the order would be after him, if tey knew however that it was planned they wouldnt show the same passion. we'll see what happens in the last book.

to add to this i always got the impression that dumbledore trusted snape with his life. this offers more evidence that he would even go through with this plan.

but there are alot of points that lead evidence the Snape is a bastard. i personally think that snape is evil however there are so many hints to say otherwise that they cant be ingored, my gut is saying he is good, my mind is saying hes a jackass.
Post
#124575
Topic
Harry Potter *Spoilers* (Serious Discussions Only, No Flaming)
Link
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/124575/action/topic#124575
Time
Quote
Originally posted by: TheSessler
BTW, what are your thoughts on who R.A.B. is?

I'm almost positive it has to be Regulus Black.


i knew there was a RB but i couldnt think of it. but isnt he dead? also there is the fact that the house would go to him as would kreacher when siris died.


he guys this it just a thought but ther prodominant thought at the end of the book was that the schol was closing, you think its possible that the next book might take place more then year after this one?

another thing, ow i know everything points against this, but i dont think snape is bad, even after killing dumbledore. i have been getting the idea that it was planned, that the whole thing was planned. the way you look at it snape was bound to kill dumbledore it is possible that he knew this, thats why he started harry's training giving him all the knowledge to beat Voldemort. i dont knwo there just somthing about it. why didnt snape do something to harry rather then deflect all of his hexes. he also told the DEs to leave harry, they could have done something like bind harry and taken him with them to voldemort if the darklord really wanted to resevere harry for himself. also back to the thing with dumbledore, dumbledore trusted him for somereason, and always made it apperent that he was hiding something, refuse to beleive it was all for dramatic effect in the book.

one other thought is again maybe dumbledores trust for snape, his love for him will play a role in the last book, snape owes dumbledore alot. and he kill him in cold blood. also i think dumbledore was dieing as it was after the potion he drank. so it was only a matter of time, it was possible that snape saw this and acted to shorten AD misery and also give hism a chance to gain more trust in the DE society, so that when the time was right he could strike. there is just something about that whole relationship that is not quite right, snape and AD.

also i got that snape was the halfblood prince at the halfway point what about you guys.

Post
#124573
Topic
Harry Potter *Spoilers* (Serious Discussions Only, No Flaming)
Link
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/124573/action/topic#124573
Time
Quote
Originally posted by: ricarleite
You know, when I watched on the news all those media-brainwashed kids waiting until midnight with their "credit card parents" to buy a copy of the latest Harry Potter book while true literature is forgotten or ignored, I was reminded of Fahrenheit 451. But then again, I reminded of myself on the midnight line to see ROTS, so...

But regarding those Harry Potter books, I'd rather read good old Kafka, thank you very much, no matter how much those crappy teenage fantasy book sell.


you obviously dont know literature well then... sry ric but to call the books crappy is just false you can say you didn't like them, but they are by no means crappy