JeromeTheEditor

I’m glad that maul is now in the film more and has more to do. Well done!

That was more impactful

Loved your first two prequel edits! Good luck on this!😃

New version is out! There is no color grading and some other minor differences

New/updated version is out. I also put the first part of the end credits and put them in the beginning of the film.

This is being updated with better editing. Most likely it will be out today or tomorrow.

The music fits the scene well!

ForceGhostRecon said:

What release date are you shooting for here?? this looks great!

He said about 2-3 months from now on one of his videos.

jarbear said:

IlFanEditore said:

I just remembered that Rebels season 2’s ending clearly says that Vader is Anakin, so to watch everything in chronological order, that should be edited too.
It is impossible to fix everything by just working on Episode III. We should at the very least work on Episode IV and Rebels too.

Anyway… another Color Correction here.
This is the “bubble theatre” panoramic view.

ORIGINAL: https://imgur.com/a/EFzTzYn

EDITED: https://imgur.com/a/VEpYlfb

There is no way to completely edit the movie to keep the “reveal” of Anakin from ALL of the Star Wars Movies, Shows, Comics, etc. The best you can do are the edits you are thinking of AND if you edit ANH. Essentially these kinds of edits would need to be focused on JUST the movies. So you sit down and watch them in order JUST by the movies.

I agree

I love the color correcting you have done so far, it makes the film feel a bit more dark,great job!

I’ll be updating this with better editing and bringing down the colors because it was a bit too much. Hopefully it will be my last version.

LordZerome1080 said:

JeromeTheEditor said:

IlFanEditore said:

IMPORTANT QUESTION!

Does anyone have an HD version of the deleted scenes? I’d like to use some of them.
They are nowhere to be found on the web.

You can use Hal’s version in ”Labriyth of evil”. The quality that he uses for his deleted scenes are actually pretty good

Or NFBISM’s which are superb as well. I have the edit if you want.

That one is also great!

IlFanEditore said:

IMPORTANT QUESTION!

Does anyone have an HD version of the deleted scenes? I’d like to use some of them.
They are nowhere to be found on the web.

You can use Hal’s version in ”Labriyth of evil”. The quality that he uses for his deleted scenes are actually pretty good

Looking forward to this!

I also prefer the second one, the only thing is that the volume is to loud when the emperor says “a powerful sith you will become” so it’s a bit hard to hear, but other than that it is good!

Looks good!

I like the original one a little bit better, but I wouldn’t mind if you used the new dark blue.

It looks good, looking forward to your edit!

Can i also get a link?

Can I also get a private message?

I dont think it came off confusion, I actually like the idea of making it regular to show that we are now in a correct chronological order. It was just the transition felt abrupt and the editing made the scene feel a little rushed, but if you can’t fix it thats totally fine because as you said, mauls story arc was not complete.

Everything worked for me it was just the ending with twins suns. My problem with it was that it felt kind of choppy with the filters but after when Darth Maul hits the fire with his lightsaber and there were no more filters it was fine.

Anakin Starkiller said:

Only criticisms is probably just some of the editing was off a bit, but other than that this was really good.

I mean that’s literally everything. It is a fan edit, after all.

True

I watched this edit and I really think it tells the story of Maul really well. It did a pretty good job of incorporating twin suns and it felt pretty consistent with the characters and the story. Only criticisms is probably just some of the editing was off a bit, but other than that this was really good.

I liked it but maybe a better transition into ”twins suns” when obi wan says “Darth Maul alive”. I think it would be better if it did not fade out.