logo Sign In

Gieferg

User Group
Members
Join date
7-Dec-2009
Last activity
9-Dec-2014
Posts
30

Post History

Post
#389758
Topic
Idea: a Dark Knight: IMAX Cut fan edit?
Time

And Transformers 2 is a different beast entirely, since the IMAX cut actually featured differences in footage (extended fight sequences, I believe), while The Dark Knight's 35mm and IMAX cuts are exactly the same with the exception of aspect ratio.

transformers 2 IMAX sequences are presented in exactly the same way as TDK is. The fact that there is also 30 seconds of additional footage have nothing to do with it.

And no, I don't think creating a version for 4:3 TVs is pointless, especially if you want to recreate the IMAX experience of a shift from 2.39:1 to 1.44:1 as closely as possible. 

If someone wants to watch non-anamorphic movie on 4:3 TV or even anamorphic on 16x9 TV with black bars on both sides during IMAX sequences, yes, in that case it makes sense.

My point is, it could easily be done, but whether it needs to be or not is up for debate.

That is right.

I think that BR version handles aspect ratio switch the best possible way for home viewing.

 

Post
#389691
Topic
Idea: a Dark Knight: IMAX Cut fan edit?
Time

false

No. He said:

Could these be integrated into a cut of the movie (Revenge of the Fallen "Big Screen Edition" Style) as a single fan edit?

I have answered to that question and ROTF Big Screen Edition style is exactly the same as TDK on BR (1.78 for IMAX sequences).

 

and possibly the fullscreen DVD) uses more picture information on the top and bottom than the Blu-Ray cut does,

I really doubt it.

 I think that fullscreen DVD is just cropped from widescreen, or in best case it is open matte which means that it may have more information on top & bottom than widescreen (but not more than BR), but still less on both sides.

But I have not seen fullscreen DVD (really, who would want to watch it? ;) ).

 

while this theoretical version would be the definitive IMAX cut for 4:3 TVs.

Right, but dont you think that creating version especially for 4:3 TVs is rather pointless?

Post
#388089
Topic
Transformers ROTF: Gieferg's Cut - (Released)
Time

Hi.

The problem with links is my fault. I forgot to login to my collector's account and some parts expired. So temporarily only avi 1.2 version is available (2DVD version was 1.1). I wasnt reuploading DVD cause I'm workin on updated version 1.3, and when it will be finished I will let you know. It will be released as Single Layer NTSC DVD.

Here's the list of changes for version 1.3:

- Twins completely removed from Shanghai (no ice-cream truck) NEW
- dialogue between Sam and his parents at the beginning trimmed
- kitchen-bots trimmed
- humping dogs removed
- some of Sam’s mom scenes deleted
- garage scene replaced with alternate version from exclusive promotional footage
- crying Bumblebee cut
- arrival to Diego Garcia rearranged, some shots trimmed, one shot of Optimus from trailer added, Twins removed (we see them only in their new alt modes) NEW
- Epps alternate trailer line after Optimus transforms added
- Leo’s pals trimmed
- cut all Sam’s parents scenes at the college
- added Sam, Leo & Alice scene at the dorm NEW
- cut Sam, Leo & friends going to the party
- cut Sam & Alice in Bumblebee
- trimmed Wheelie trying to get the shard (no mouse trap, less talking)
- Sam is freaking out in his room a little less
- cut Leo’s reaction on Sam in his room
- most of the dialogue between Sam and Mikaela during escape deleted
- cut Leo’s “So hot” line
- part of the Paris scenes deleted
- twins removed from Sam & Leo discussion scene
- cut part of Decepticons arrival
- part of Simmons dialogue removed
- “don’ tell my mother” removed
- some of Wheelie’s lines removed
- Simmons ass and dialogue before going to museum cut
- cut Leo’s toilet scene
- removed Leo line “I’m not going anywhere” when Simmons paralyzing the guard
- humping wheelie removed
- cut part of Jetfire dialogue and parachute scene
- cut the scene in which Mikaela lies on Leo
- added "Leo refuses..." deleted scene NEW
- Galloway plane and Egypt scenes removed
- Leo & Simmons sleeping removed (cut improved)
- Leo’s panic in the car removed
- paralyzing Leo removed
- cut part of dialogue between Leo and Simmons
- part of Headquarters talking deleted
- deleted some of the footage from aircraft carrier, flying jets etc.
- removed “enemy scrotum”
- cut “Transformers heaven”
- cut one shot of Optimus after his resurrection which was used twice
And for fans of 80's Transformers and TF:TM:
- added Stan Bush - The Touch as soundtrack in final battle* NEW (but present also in version1.2)
- Linkin Park song replaced with Stan Bush – Till all are one - added some G1 transformation sounds here and there NEW



* yeah, maybe it's cheesy, but I like this not so great fight (Bay was apologising for it on his commentary) more with it, Original version didn't have any good score in it, and was really lacking in any emotions. I've watched it about 50-60 times with the song, and now when I am watching original version it feels like something's missing.