Figrin_Dan

User Group: Members
Join date: 19-Jul-2004
Last activity: 17-Jan-2005
Posts: 77

Post History

Post: #55458
Topic: Episode I-VI: Archival Editions
Link: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/55458/action/topic#55458
Time: 19-Jul-2004 6:11 PM

So because its posted online it has to be true right? I read most of these and while I like to think some of them are really cool and would add greater consistency to the movies as a saga, I believe most of it is fan boy speculation. I don't believe George has decided on what will eventually be included on the 'archival' editions in 2007. He can never make up his mind so don't take this list as anything but rumours in my opinion. I mean come on, Anakin "apologises" for all the things he did wrong and says "it is done"? Please......if this list came from Starwars.com, then I could believe it.

Post: #55456
Topic: Cringe Factor
Link: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/55456/action/topic#55456
Time: 19-Jul-2004 6:06 PM

I thought it would be interesting to see what is the ultimate, the most gut wrenchingly, embarrassing moment of the PT. Unlike the OT, I don't watch the movie and at any point want to press the "fast forward" button. So, here's your chance to vent your spleen about a particular scene, a line of dialogue, a thematic or plot idea.

Mine would definitely be in AOTC and the fireplace scene with Padme and Anakin. Anakin's entire dialogue is pitiful, absolutely shocking. But the one that seals it is something like "my heart is hoping, hoping that kiss does not turn into a scar...." Absolute tripe, nothing like the romance of Empire or ANH.

Who's next?