Would you considering making updates to the already made books, in the future? Such as fixing up the volume?
I personally also don’t agree with making the first two movies dark like the later ones.
They were perfect with their rich, colorful, and whimsical tone, perfectly in line with the first two books.
And Prisoner of Azkaban should have also been made in the same style. I know that I wound up falling in love with the Prisoner of Azkaban we got, but I still wish the tone of the first two movies could have continued for the later films. Maybe somewhat darker, but not all way into the direction they went.
JJ, if you decide to release your own extended editions of movies 1 and 2, I’d love to see that.
All right, that sound reasonable.
Question though: will you continue to use music from the older movie / game in the future books, or stick with the newer music tracks?
Somebody had made a “Fan Soundtrack” for Hogwarts Legacy. Two tracks so far, but they might make more.
Check it out, and maybe you can ask permition to use these, if you like them?
In addition to using the OPEN MATTE versions, maybe some few improvements from Doctor M’s The Enhanced ABC Cut could be used?
Now, a few more random ideas, though I have no idea how well this could work
- Consistancy with the use of Polyjuice Potion. It should either always change the voice, or always keep the voice.
- In Chamber of Secrets, the diary memories had a certain color tint to it. Maybe apply it to the Pensieve memory scenes in the other movies, for a consistant look?
Overall, making magic spells and effects consistant is something that can really improve the experience.
By the way, do you think you could do the Jim Dale (US) versions sometime in the future, too?
I personally prefer Stephen Fry’s versions, there are a lot of fans of Jim Dale, too.
Happy New Year!
Loved listening to these so far, and I’m looking forward to the series continuing 😃
Happy New Year, JJ !
I am so happy that you have re-released your edits, so that more people can experience them 😃
I’m really curious about your idea of deepfaking Richard Harris. While I’m personally prefer Richard Harris’ portray of Dumbledor then Michael Gambon - that does largely come to the acting. Who knows, maybe a more consistant appearance would be nice.
Plus, I’d love to watch movies 1-2 with your edits, too.
I hope you keep the light tone of them though. We already have a different fan edit that makes them darker.
Any hints to what else would be different in movies 1-2 compared to the official director’s cut?
Didn’t they steal your content then?
So, here’s an idea.
The current version of Order doesn’t restore the “Trelawney during Umbridge’s speech” scenes.
However, I once saw a (much lower quality) fan edit that did in fact restore it.
It combined both the official Umbridge scene with the deleted Trelawney scene, by alternating between the two characters.
From what I remember, it looked decent, and could work in this fan edit.
I could trim out that scene to demonstrate it, if anyone wants to see.
I love Over the Garden Wall. It’s a great mini-series.
But, being that it’s so short, I’m thinking of combining all the episodes into a movie.
In theory, this shouldn’t be too hard. If I just merge all the episodes together, and remove the title cards / credits from them, as well as add some fade out effects between them.
But what would I do about the end credits?
I would want this movie edit to have end credits, that takes all the names of everyone who worked on this series.
Would this need to be re-animated then? Can anyone help me with that?
I’m also thinking of adding in the “Tome of the Unknown” pilot into this fan edit. Between episodes 3 and 4 seems like a good place for it, in theory.
Here’s Tome, uploaded to YouTube by the official Cartoon Network channel: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X-0vZeaIrFg
I know this has some inconsistencies from the original series, but I think I might be able to work around them.
The dialogue mentioning searching for the book can be replaced by some dialogue from the original series of searching for Adelaide, and Wirt’s surprised reaction to the living vegetable or the car could be edited out. The narration can also be replaced with just the music. Because the original series only had narration at the very start and very end, and I think it would be better to stay that way.
However, there are still two problems with Tome of the Unknown that wouldn’t be as easily fixable.
- Beatrice is voiced by a different actress here, so there would be an inconsistency of voices.
- It ends with them riding on Goose, but, of course, Goose is nowhere in the main series, and I don’t think there’s even any audio dialogue that could be used to explain where Goose went to.
So, would it even be practical to include Tome of the Unknown into this edit?
Such dedication for a Thomas the Tank Engine movie?
Well, I surely admire the effort.
Is the og movie that good then?
You can NOT remove the Up prologue.
To add to my previous post,
JJ, you don’t have to update us too often, but I hope you can give us updates on your progress once in a while.
That said, stick to “tell, don’t show” this time. Only way to avoid what happened last time is to not release any early footage.
I absolutely loved how the season 5 finale of LOST ended with a white-out, and just when you expect the white screen to transition to the next scene, all of the sudden, the LOST logo appears, in black letters, a complete invert of the usual end card, and a complete invert of expectations. “That’s it? THAT’S where you end the episode and season?”
What disappointed me is that this brilliant move was followed by the regular credits, which, to me, slightly lowered the emotional impact.
So, here’s what I did for this edit.
First of, I used the combined long version of “The Incident” from the US version Blue-ray.
Changes made to the ending:
- slightly extended the part from when the screen goes white to when the LOST logo appears, for added tension
- after LOST logo appears, all audio is removed from the rest of the credits, including the staff names, and the Bad Robot / ABC logos.
- shortened the transition between the LOST logo disappearing and the staff names starting, because, without a fade to black or music, the downtime would be too long, and not needed in this place.
- The main part of the credits with all the staff names has a color invert effect applied to it, making black names on white background, matching up with what happens with the logo. (Bad Robot and ABC retain normal colors, because they would become super uncanny inverted).
Demo clip: https://youtu.be/rLlYBfkFI-k
Everything else remains the same.
Send me a PM for download.
You MUST own the LOST Season 5 Blue-ray.
And if you ever get to watch LOST together with somebody who hasn’t seen it before, go ahead and show them this version. Let me know what sort of emotions they’d get from the ending the credits specifically.
The effect I’m hoping for is somebody just sitting with their jaw dropped, or staring at the screen is silent confusion.
Anakin Starkiller said:
I haven’t seen the Fantastic Beasts films. David Yates’ Doctor Who is a bullet I’m glad we dodged (supposedly it really did come close to happening), so I’m not keen on a stand-in. Are the movies any good? I do plan on seeing them eventually.
The first Fantastic Beasts film is actually one of my favorite movies in general.
It works good as a stand-alone film, so you could watch it, without bothering with its sequel.
I don’t mind the Marvel style of the intros. New ones still do it well.
But what I liked about the old ones was:
- Perfect pacing. 30 seconds is a good length, while 50 feels dragged out.
- Variety of music, with each one being fitting for its own film. Considering many people (myself included) love to marathon the movies, having them play the same music every time would get tiring.
- Lack of spoilers. That’s important, I know there are still people who are just getting into Harry Potter and starting with the movies instead of the books.
I hope you aren’t upset by the criticism, and can take these factors into consideration.
I’m really happy to hear you are back to this project.
Hope everything goes well for you.
I admire the effort you put into the new intros. They do look really good.
Sorry to say I’m not as big of a fan of these. They feel much slower, the music doesn’t feel as fun. It’s very upbeat and brings up hype, but not as magical / whimsical.
But mostly, these intros show of some actual scenes, such as Voldemort getting the Elder Wand.
I know these are technically made for yourself, and shared with those who are already fans of the HP movies.
But I can still see somebody watching your fan edits as their very first time watching the movies (if somebody recommends it to them, which I totally would do, when / if you bring them back, I would recommend anyone who hasn’t seen the films to just go straight to your fan edits), thus those scenes being spoilers.
Just sharing my opinion.
Either way, good luck with the project, wherever it goes now.
I’ve been racking my brain at the comment that the S4 and S5 finales are preserved in their original double-length forms on Blu because…they aren’t. At least, not on my sets, and I’ve been scouring the Internet for any BDrip uploads that have the movie length S4 and S5 finales, and have found nothing - they’re all split.
I was talking to SpacemanDoug about it, and after a while he finally dug up some info - they’re only preserved on the US Region A releases. I imported the UK sets because they were cheaper at the time, and apparently all the scene uploaders also used an international set for their rips and uploads.
Man. That really sucks, I didn’t want to have to re-buy them…
I think I may have found the original double versions of the S4 and S5 finales.
I’m pretty sure I’m not allowed to give download link, but I’m assuming I can provide you vague directions if you PM me about it.
never mind, they turned out to be low quality tv rips
I’m definitely only supporting you, and not getting a shady edit made by a thief.
But I am sad that I wouldn’t be able to share your project with anyone.
I’m really sorry you had to deal with such a terrible fate.
Yeah, having your content stolen really sucks.
I already have your editions.
I haven’t had time to get to fully watch all of them. But I’ve seen enough to be able to appreciate your hard work and dedication. Not to mention the sweet editing skills.
Well, I myself am somebody who found these edits from Google, joined to ask for them, and never became part of this community.
This is just the only project on this website that I’ve been interested in, and I didn’t have much to talk about in other forum sections.
Guess it doesn’t make me that good of a user on this forum, but that’s just how things are…
But I fully understand you though. I’ve had times when people I thought were good really let me down, and then I didn’t know who to trust.
I still hope that some day, you can return to this project, and make new versions available.
But if not, I just want to thank you for all the hard work you did.
I was wondering, do your extended editions come with subtitles? I’d love the links to them anyway but I find subtitles particularly useful.
Yep. The subtitles are embeded directly into the video files (no seperate SRT file needed), so should work in VLC.
Send a PM to JJPotter to receive the files.
Sorry to hear about your loss.
Take care of yourself.
I will be following this topic, and I hope some day you update DH-1 with the complete Dudley scene, or other updates you might do.
But for now, just take care of yourself.
And to other people reading this topic - send JJPotter a PM to get a download.
He does not provide them via request here.