Sadako said:
If Janeway had originally been the First Officer and chief Science Officer (and had thus worn Science Blue for the entire series), and the original captain had been killed in the series premier and then she had to be acting captain, I don't think I would mind Janeway's horrible command style as much.
If 'Janeway is a Science Officer who had the command of an imperiled vessel thrust upon her; now she must learn the ropes of being a captain while trying to get her vessel and crew home safely' had been the basis of her character arc, then her lack of tact and horrible screw-ups would be expected--she's learning. As a Science Officer, she wouldn't be expected to be a tactful diplomat with advanced training in first contact scenarios or negotiating with a hostile party.
Yes and what is more it would set up a basis for conflict between her and Chakota(Did I spell that right? I don't care the last two weeks have been the hardest of my life and I am running on fumes.)He would be a better tactical commander but because Janeway had more people and the working ship he would have to defer to her but he would not like it and what is more she would be wrong sometimes. Over the course of the show they could learn that while neither one of them had the all the skills needed to get their crews home they each hand some of them and they both cared deeply about their crews so that would bring them together and it would make them a team that could get almost anything done. We would get to see the distrust tern to friendship over the run of the show and Chakota would get something to do other then talk endlessly about his people.
I don't know about you but that is a plot and character arc that I would watch over and over again. I mean think about it season one Janeway and Chakota would be completely different people from their season seven selves and the friendship would feel earned and then when something threatened it the viewers would care because we had seen it grew from nothing and thus we wouldn't want to see it undone.
I would love to see that show,it's a shame we didn't get it:(