logo Sign In

CHEWBAKAspelledwrong

User Group
Members
Join date
8-Jan-2016
Last activity
5-Jul-2025
Posts
3,415

Post History

Post
#1239455
Topic
The Criterion Collection Thread
Time

SilverWook said:

The older Strangelove Blu is no slouch though. Just watched it again recently. I’m really hoping Criterion gets to do The Shining, as there’s room for improvement on the decade old HD master.

According to Bill Hunt’s review the two Strangelove blus are based on the same transfer (a 4K scan of various second +generation elements (the O-neg, I believe, was destroyed). The Criterion is just a more modern mastering of that transfer, which looks incredible considering the neg is lost.

Post
#1239154
Topic
The Criterion Collection Thread
Time

moviefreakedmind said:

Yeah, I’d love a Criterion OT. I’d be stunned to death if that happened, though. You should get Dr. Strangelove from Criterion, and Spartacus but that one seems to have vanished from print lately, which is tragic.

I want to see Philadelphia and Boys Don’t Cry in the Criterion Collection. Those have never gotten good blu-ray releases in the United States (or anywhere else that I’m aware, but at least they are available in HD). There’re also a couple of Polish movies I had to watch in college a few years ago that I hope get added because they aren’t available now anywhere that I can find. I should write to them and tell them to add those, I know they consider requests.

I’ll list my complete collection when I get home. It’s not huge or anything, but it’s more than I can remember off the top of my head.

I have a region-free UK edition of Strangelove that I got cheaply before the criterion release that I’m happy with. Spartacus was only ever DVD from Criterion, I believe. Universal’s second stab at the Blu, though, (the “Restored Edition”) is quite nice.

I guess in short, I buy Criterion because they have movies I want, not because I think they’re better than other editions (which they are, I just don’t care enough to replace movies I already own unless it’s a noticeable jump in main-feature transfer quality).

Post
#1239140
Topic
The Criterion Collection Thread
Time

I got into Criterion because I love Kubrick, and some of his less popular films are only available in the Criterion Collection for region A.

So far I’ve acquired Barry Lyndon, Paths of Glory, and The Killing. The first two are great; I haven’t yet watched the third.

I also picked up Asphalt Jungle ‘cause it caught my eye on the shelf next to Lyndon. While not a great film, it was very fun, and I’d watch it again.

I might pick up Some Like it Hot once it starts showing up on sale, and I’ll certainly keep up with their new offerings in case anything catches my eye.