Angel

Darth Solo said:

(EDIT) vaderios beat me to it. And there is a lot of this going around lately too....

SPOOKEY!

I dont get it :P

The Golden Idol said:

So, no one else noticed the bad compositing/outlines of Lando, Leia and Chewie on the balcony? I'm sure it's ILM's fault and not Ady's, but is there any way to fix it? It sticks out.

I said that in the first post after ady post the trailer ;)

Check it

-Angel

Sluggo said:

 Nice!  I think the camera shake starts a bit too early, bit I like the concept.

I came up with the idea that is cool the bridge going shaking as the a wing engines come closer and closer.

-Angel

fishmanlee said:

i just want the scene because there is music for it

Nice...

I prefer to keep all the hidden music to replace some poor stuff for PT :)

^And edit your posts ;)

-Angel

I agree.... It was the great age of the great posters...

-Angel

I m not a fan of flashbacks or dreams. Its not Star wars-y.

I like that less is more.

-Angel

Bring more nude :)

See a test :)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HQ9C9zw4n1I

-Angel

Ripplin said:

^^In other other words, vaderios should make one himself (or modify that one, if he's allowed) so he'll be satisfied. Ha!

Maybe i will think or make a poster at summer when i am on vacations :)

-Angel

Nope. The deathstar supposed to be under the belly of the executor.

And you can see clearly that is stage because its visible the black screen that supposed to be space

-Angel

fredstar said:

Some things to make it better.

Eliminate the damn photoshop lens flares and use custom ones ;)

All the heroes are fade exept the Droids and boba. if you want to pop up, make them in different size.

Some slight motion blur to snow speeder.

Luke has some bad outlines. Manage to have all the heroes a uniform color and sharpness

Sabers can not overlap.

You have MF on the top right when the top left is empty, bad balance.

The orange sky thing dont work so well. maybe an other sky.

Add an asteroid field somewhere maybe.

You don't leave space for any titles.

Thats some things than can make it better

My 2 Credits.

-Angel

I say yes to Lasers because it adds more color to the scene. Also eliminates the chances that the eye  focus on bad masks and mattes.

How about the Tie fighters have pink laser color? (jk ofc)

-Angel

Last for today because i forgot i have exams.... :S

-Angel

gavin77 said:

I must be on total crack, but I must have missed Doubleofives visual comparison shots? I've read every page, where are the comparisons? Are they the ones on page 1, or did he do some new ones? Thanks

http://picasaweb.google.com/doubleofive/ESBRTrailerComparison

-Angel

Executor Bridge! How wonderful :)

Pity i cant say the same for ROTJ version of it.

Based on ESB matte-set then:

I post that in some big rez to see some details or what.

I hate dead blacks...

Does it matter that I see the Studio Set instead of space?

-Angel

There is a way but its secret lol

-Angel

Josh said:

Just little "nit picks" I have with it, I kinda liked the original background when luke is walking through the building, they kinda distract me. It also looked slightly grainy, but I understand.

On noes!  That particular one is one od my favorite parts :)

In fact... The buildings have the correct perpespective but it should have a blue shadow tint because of the sky reflection :)

Otisburg... Otisburg? (lol)

-Angel

Vader's voice is lightyears better than in ANH. Im impressed!

I think they used a mixed filter between ESB and ANH.

Who is it that did the voice for the Holiday Special Fett?

Don Francks

-Angel

doubleofive said:

EDIT: look at the different colors in every shot!  Who quality checked this thing?!

Does it matter...? ;)

In fact i was impressed by your breakdown 005!

Changing the panels and the color is an indication that is an other place.

I can always wanted some same filmed shots to be replaced by some way. More zoom or tilt or or...

-Angel

Considering the ESB and ROTS comparison you made 005, i was wondering why Ady uses the same footage again. The officers will do the same gesture as teh falcon fly by over the bridge. ROTS officers would do a good job for hard working men.

EDIT: You beat me Sevb lol

Also there is an FX glitch in the laser firing when the ties are hunting the MF in the new Star destroyer shot. ( when the up right TIE shoots near the end the laser isnt moving properly and overlap the tie itself. Its not ady's fault)

-Angel

digitalfreaknyc said: ADY IS A GOD!

Kneel Before ZOD!

-Angel

Darth Lars said:

Is it just me, or ... does that Imperial Tech in the middle look a lot like Zachary Quinto? Coincidence?

They said that in the new star trek movie there is an R2 unit in it.

You spot the Spock in the Star wars:)

What was the winning Prize?

-Angel

Awesome! Boba at his shining age! Before the dark times...before the cosmic rust.

-Angel

Janskeet said:

Adywan, did you rip this footage from ROTS?

I suppose that vader is from ROTS. The other plate is a mirrored shot when the MF flyby from Needa's bridge.

ChainsawAsh: Yeah most likely i messed up the layers... :P

-Angel

corellian77 said:

005, got those comparison pics yet?

Some that cause my attention :)

The rest from 005

Edit: I just noticed that Vader's Chest lights in the scene after han is tortured, when lando and vadie are talking, aren't moving... Perhaps a ANH:R treatment?

-Angel

Oh nice... The trailer :)

Edit: Wow! just wow!

I have something to say. I love the emperor, the cloud city clouds. the blue engine of falcon and the retraction pads.

I d love to keep the lasers that the TIES firing at MF at the asteroid chase( adds more color to the scene)

Impressive duel shot! (still Sabers never have a motion blur)

I love the subtle window frame that you put when leia is firing.

nice to see that you powered up the Shot that luke enters to Cloud City.

When Leia lando and chewie are running at the balcony scene, impressive sky still very blury masks.

I could expect something more like color dodge or linear dodge blue to luke's face from saber light

Thats all for now

-Angel