So Episode 1 came out when I was 6 and while I distinctly remember the experience of seeing it in theaters, I don’t remember whether or not I had seen the original trilogy before or after it. I only know that by the time it had come out on VHS, I had seen the original trilogy. I really enjoyed the prequels as a kid and just kind of took the prequels at face value with regards to Anakin’s transformation into Darth Vader and it worked for me. In fact, it wasn’t until I left for college that I knew people even disliked the prequels my dad liked them, my brother liked them, and most of my friends that were into Star Wars liked them, so it was really a shock to see how much hatred the prequels had gotten. Of course, watching them today, well 3 years ago was the last time I saw all of the prequels in their entirety, it’s easy to see that they aren’t great movies. Phantom Menace is ok I guess, the main problems were too much juvenile humor, and a lot of the movie is really slow and plodding. The story on paper is really good, but in execution, it’s just kind of boring to watch. There are exciting moments, I liked the underwater sequence, their flight from Naboo, the pod race is great and I think the entire climax is really fun, but they’re just too far and in between. Attack of the Clones was much better as it’s not boring to sit through. The pacing is fine, and the action was upped, but Anakin is pretty grating early on in the film. Revenge of the Sith is I think a legitimately good movie it’s got its issues with acting and some character moments being really forced, but overall I enjoy watching the movie.
With regards to Anakin’s transformation into Darth Vader I don’t really have an issue with it. I think most people’s complaints are that what ends up being his main motivation should have been his side motivation, and vice versa. I think what really sabotages this is that the romance between Anakin and Padme for a lot of people isn’t well handled or executed. Personally outside of the first act of Attack of the Clones, I don’t really have a problem with their romance. Sure the dialogue is really cringy but I actually don’t hate their romance on Naboo and I was really surprised at, when during my last watch-through, how much I liked it. I think years of hearing people shit on it, and not having watched the movie unedited in years eventually overrode my own opinion on it. Don’t get me wrong I do think most of the complaints about their romance are valid, but there’s something about it that just clicks for me. I don’t really know how to explain it or understand why I like it myself, maybe it’s nostalgia or maybe it’s that I have a soft spot for that type of melodrama, but for me, it works.
I think the main thing is that George Lucas’s directions for Hayden’s acting are just awful and they make scenes that should work fail. His conversation with Padme, while she’s packing for her trip, is one of them. His thoughts that while he looks at Obi-Wan like he’s his father, but feels constrained by his teaching and that he’s being held back. And that he wants more even though he knows he shouldn’t would be really compelling, but because of the directing and acting it feels like a childish tantrum. We get a really good look at Anakin’s own political views during his romance scene with Padme on Naboo, but it’s sandwiched between romance stuff people hate. It’s one of the reasons why the novelizations for the prequel trilogy are superior to the movies, it takes away the poor acting and directing that obfuscates the storytelling and character work that’s actually going on.
So Anakin’s reason for turning to the dark side being about trying to protect the galaxy or to gain more power because he’s frustrated by the Jedi seemingly holding him back are in Revenge of the Sith, but because they’re shown as side motivations and the romance hasn’t been done well since it’s the main motivation I can understand why it doesn’t work for so many people. Maybe it’s also because I read the novelization for Revenge of the Sith before the movie came out that some of the character work the novel does might also be contributing to it as well, but I thought the execution of it in movie 3 works really well. It also helps that the scene preceding his decision is kept 100% silent and focuses on the facial acting of Padme and Anakin, that makes it works for me.