logo Sign In

The Last Jedi: The De-Feminized Fanedit — Page 5

This topic has been locked by a moderator.

Why was this topic locked?

Let it rot.

Author
Time

Hal 9000 said:

The First Order was equally diverse as the Resistance, if not more so.

We need to cut out Phasma though.

Author
Time

darthrush said:

TV’s Frink said:

Hal 9000 said:

The First Order was equally diverse as the Resistance, if not more so.

We need to cut out Phasma though.

Some people want to cut her down for other reasons than being sexist but oh well.

Yeah I know but that’s for a different thread. This one’s for making women learn their place!

Author
Time

TV’s Frink said:

darthrush said:

TV’s Frink said:

Hal 9000 said:

The First Order was equally diverse as the Resistance, if not more so.

We need to cut out Phasma though.

Some people want to cut her down for other reasons than being sexist but oh well.

Yeah I know but that’s for a different thread. This one’s for making women learn their place!

Sorry, I misunderstood your post. I almost forgot what thread I was in.

Return of the Jedi: Remastered

Lord of the Rings: The Darth Rush Definitives

Author
Time

It’s not even as if Phasma was such a developed character she would annoy sexist people anyway… her and Hux are really something in those movies (are they related to vice-Roy Gunray ? I guess so…)

Author
Time

adywan said:

Vladius said:

I realize this might be an unpopular opinion here, but aside from the portrayal of Luke (which some people feel is just a matter of interpretation,) the non-Rey female characters were easily the worst parts of the film.
They have the most cringe-inducing dialogue:…“if you need to see the sun shining to know it’s there, you’ll never last through the night,” …

A line not even spoken in the film. If you are going to use quotes to prove a point about bad dialogue, at least get the quote right. That’s not even close.

You’re being needlessly pedantic and it absolutely is close.

Author
Time

Vladius said:

adywan said:

Vladius said:

I realize this might be an unpopular opinion here, but aside from the portrayal of Luke (which some people feel is just a matter of interpretation,) the non-Rey female characters were easily the worst parts of the film.
They have the most cringe-inducing dialogue:…“if you need to see the sun shining to know it’s there, you’ll never last through the night,” …

A line not even spoken in the film. If you are going to use quotes to prove a point about bad dialogue, at least get the quote right. That’s not even close.

You’re being needlessly pedantic and it absolutely is close.

You’re saying it’s a bad line, in which case the phrasing does matter.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

And this bloke got given a whole trilogy as in 3 more films with this sort of dialogue… HA HA HA HA.

Amazing the stupidness is.

Author
Time

Ronster said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

R U OK MY FRIEND?

Author
Time

Ronster said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

And this bloke got given a whole trilogy as in 3 more films with this sort of dialogue… HA HA HA HA.

Amazing the stupidness is.

Who wrote this trash?

Oh right, ronster.

Author
Time

DominicCobb said:

Ronster said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

And this bloke got given a whole trilogy as in 3 more films with this sort of dialogue… HA HA HA HA.

Amazing the stupidness is.

Who wrote this trash?

Oh right, ronster.

No mate what i wrote was not the sort of sycofantic trash that you gobble up like some sort of heroin addict.

I treat films for what they are. It does not matter if it is a franchise ora stand alone film. Actually i despise all the Marvel franchise and the best films from last year I would say was “The Witch” and “High Rise” both totally new ground covered not your run of the mill shallow churned out machine blockbuster. It’s over for me all of this crappy superficial nonsence I am most certainly done. I prefer films with some sort of substance that i can relate to as a human and even if they give a different slant on realty i can still relate to it and understand.

But i am not the person who eats popcorn and feels a desire to stuff my face relentlessly because i am watching a film. This is the truth. Read and weap if you care too…

Author
Time

Ronster said:

DominicCobb said:

Ronster said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

And this bloke got given a whole trilogy as in 3 more films with this sort of dialogue… HA HA HA HA.

Amazing the stupidness is.

Who wrote this trash?

Oh right, ronster.

No mate what i wrote was not the sort of sycofantic trash that you gobble up like some sort of heroin addict.

I treat films for what they are. It does not matter if it is a franchise ora stand alone film. Actually i despise all the Marvel franchise and the best films from last year I would say was “The Witch” and “High Rise” both totally new ground covered not your run of the mill shallow churned out machine blockbuster. It’s over for me all of this crappy superficial nonsence I am most certainly done. I prefer films with some sort of substance that i can relate to as a human and even if they give a different slant on realty i can still relate to it and understand.

But i am not the person who eats popcorn and feels a desire to stuff my face relentlessly because i am watching a film. This is the truth. Read and weap if you care too…

i would ask again if you are ok, but …

Author
Time

Ronster said:

DominicCobb said:

Ronster said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

And this bloke got given a whole trilogy as in 3 more films with this sort of dialogue… HA HA HA HA.

Amazing the stupidness is.

Who wrote this trash?

Oh right, ronster.

No mate what i wrote was not the sort of sycofantic trash that you gobble up like some sort of heroin addict.

I treat films for what they are. It does not matter if it is a franchise ora stand alone film. Actually i despise all the Marvel franchise and the best films from last year I would say was “The Witch” and “High Rise” both totally new ground covered not your run of the mill shallow churned out machine blockbuster. It’s over for me all of this crappy superficial nonsence I am most certainly done. I prefer films with some sort of substance that i can relate to as a human and even if they give a different slant on realty i can still relate to it and understand.

But i am not the person who eats popcorn and feels a desire to stuff my face relentlessly because i am watching a film. This is the truth. Read and weap if you care too…

Haha alright man. Glad we had this talk about a movie you haven’t seen.

Personally, I can handle both blockbusters and non-blockbusters just fine. I don’t feel like I have to choose only the “better” movies to make me feel smart, but that’s just me. Believe it or not you can make a quality film that’s a blockbuster, it’s actually why we’re on this site in the first place.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

I only wish we could have the 90’s blockbusyers back! I don’t hate blockbusters at all in fact some are my favourite but it has now gone too far.

It’s become a weird detachment from reality in some of these new films and honestly this for me is too much. I don’t want to know… I will stick with more relatable films that make me realize something or teach me something, or even change my perspective on something or as little as open my mind to something different. That is the beauty of film.

You could also argue…People go to work full of politics. People read and watch news more politics… then when the desire for escapism to watch a film and yet more politics!

Interestingly i just got chatting to a fellow that made a short promo film of 4:32 about water purification and was shown all over africa. He was talking about how a shakesperian actor was hired but did not capture the right message ultimately the normal message came from him as script and producer and he ended up in the film for the water purification device and the shakesperisn actor was deleted as in never known to have existed.

Russian scientist named “Vittel” which i actually think there are Vittel mineral water bottles in circulation now… Anyway “Vittel” agreed but the guy “Cluffy” never got any royalties. Only payment on production. The film was broadcast all over africa. There is something interesting about film making… But Cool life goes on and people do good.

Author
Time

Ronster said:

DominicCobb said:

Ronster said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

And this bloke got given a whole trilogy as in 3 more films with this sort of dialogue… HA HA HA HA.

Amazing the stupidness is.

Who wrote this trash?

Oh right, ronster.

No mate what i wrote was not the sort of sycofantic trash that you gobble up like some sort of heroin addict.

I treat films for what they are. It does not matter if it is a franchise ora stand alone film. Actually i despise all the Marvel franchise and the best films from last year I would say was “The Witch” and “High Rise” both totally new ground covered not your run of the mill shallow churned out machine blockbuster. It’s over for me all of this crappy superficial nonsence I am most certainly done. I prefer films with some sort of substance that i can relate to as a human and even if they give a different slant on realty i can still relate to it and understand.

But i am not the person who eats popcorn and feels a desire to stuff my face relentlessly because i am watching a film. This is the truth. Read and weap if you care too…

Lay off the insults. Now.

Forum Moderator

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

ray_afraid said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

ALLOL
If I die at night, let it be known that it was because I didn’t believe in the sun.

I don’t get what you find so troubling with that quote.

it reminds me of all the ancient culture stories that where shared during the last eclipse (this past summer?). Lots of times in the past, people freaked out when the sun disappeared.

its not that you didn’t believe in the sun. its that you didn’t believe it was coming back…

Author
Time

ray_afraid said:

dahmage said:

its not that you didn’t believe in the sun. its that you didn’t believe it was coming back…

But just believing that won’t kill you. The morning will prove you wrong.
And if it’s true, then that reality will kill you, not your doubt in the sun.

ok, you must be tooling with me…

Author
Time

SilverWook said:

Ronster said:

DominicCobb said:

Ronster said:

snooker said:

“Hope is like the sun. If you only believe it when you see it you’ll never make it through the night.”

Who wrote this trash?

Hope is something you wish will happen for the greater good and benefit others more than yourself. I.e something that will have a greater impact than just hope you passed an exam that is not really “hope” that is personal ambition.

I am glad i never went to see this. Not interested in the edit either…

Only believe the sun when you see it? Hmmmmm…

This is totally stupid at least my opinion. I will only believe a star when i see it snarf snarf (thundercats) yes this is complete stupidity.

And this bloke got given a whole trilogy as in 3 more films with this sort of dialogue… HA HA HA HA.

Amazing the stupidness is.

Who wrote this trash?

Oh right, ronster.

No mate what i wrote was not the sort of sycofantic trash that you gobble up like some sort of heroin addict.

I treat films for what they are. It does not matter if it is a franchise ora stand alone film. Actually i despise all the Marvel franchise and the best films from last year I would say was “The Witch” and “High Rise” both totally new ground covered not your run of the mill shallow churned out machine blockbuster. It’s over for me all of this crappy superficial nonsence I am most certainly done. I prefer films with some sort of substance that i can relate to as a human and even if they give a different slant on realty i can still relate to it and understand.

But i am not the person who eats popcorn and feels a desire to stuff my face relentlessly because i am watching a film. This is the truth. Read and weap if you care too…

Lay off the insults. Now.

To be fair other people were being insulting. I am not having a fight just stating an opinion. People here often insult themselves with their comments. I am fairly on the level and not aggressive.

Author
Time

Everybody lay off the insults then.

Forum Moderator

Where were you in '77?

Author
Time
 (Edited)

SilverWook said:

Everybody lay off the insults then.

To be honest that what i would hope…, I found out about this edit through internet news and various cast members commenting on it with tear drops again and again.

It is a sad state of affairs… I don’t know that is why i say the 70’s 80’s and 90’s did it right now i do think there has been a loss of direction relating to “real” people which is gone further than before because it is so “fake” in a way and even though older films were still “fake” they just were not as fake as it is now. It’s pretty much completely unrelatable for a normal person to connect in a normal way…

The motivation of this edit is the big question.