Star Wars Episode III: Labyrinth Of Evil (Released) — Page 50

Is that in both versions? I love that change!

Hello there. If it’s no bother may I have a PM so that I may have access to your edits, please?

Hi Hal… just wanted to say I finally got the chance to check out your fanedits and I love what you’ve done. ESPECIALLY the prequel trilogy.

Even though the germ of the story is pretty great (the story, not necessarily the screenplays), there’s always been one thing that really bothered me about the way Lucas made them, and that’s his expectation that people will always watch them out of sequence (the originals first, then the prequels); because of that, they pander to fans instead of surprise us. One thing above all sticks out at me: when Padme names her children. This totally destroys the surprise of Leia being the other child for the first-time viewer watching them in episode order (and we already know she has two babies and they’re separated from other discussion.)

So, I’d like to suggest that, if you further revise Labyrith of Evil, you might consider removing her naming the twins.

Anyway, they’re works of art, so thank you for the work you’ve done. And thanks for your consideration on my suggestion. 😃

(P.S. the only other thing I wish had been left in is the Palpatine-Yoda battle, not just because it’s awesome but because it shows Yoda didn’t just give up on everything. He was defeated… which gives his payback training Vader’s son a bigger edge. Just a thought!)

This was one of the first edits I ever watched, back when it was at version 3 or 4. Congrats on reaching a point of finality on all your hard work!

I’ve only watched RotS a handful of times, but I recall thinking it was the prequel which was least in need of a fanedit. That said, I did thoroughly enjoy your LoE version and nothing jumped out at me as truncated or out-of-place. Having just listened to your commentary, it turns out a lot of the moments I enjoyed in LoE were deleted scenes you reinstated. Specifically, I like the “seeds of Rebellion” scenes, and how they dovetail with Rogue One and Andor.

I believe this is pretty much standard practice for RotS edits, but it’s still nice to see Padmé surviving too.

EDIT: I know a lot of people round here aren’t exactly keen on Disney-era Star Wars, and I don’t love it all myself; I hope you aren’t offended that I enjoy your edits and some Disney SW.

Could we get a version without letterboxing encoded into the video? I have an ultrawide monitor and it looks like this.

Hello Hal. Thank you for your awesome edits! I have watched your edits of Episode I & II and they were fantastic. I really enjoyed your focus on Padme in Ep II. She comes across as much more badass.

I’m having difficulty finding Episode III to watch. Could you help point me in the right direction?

Thanks for your work and dedication.

Hi Hal, thanks for the edit, changes look really solid. Could you help me with finding Episode III? Thanks again for the good work.

Hi there. I’m a big fan of your work especially since I hated the excessive comic relief in the first third of an otherwise masterpiece of a movie. IMO it is the best SW movie out there. Could I have access to your latest updated version please??

Forgot my original login info to this site and forgot how I previously got access to your edits and I’m missing this one. Would love to get access!

Can you send me a link please,as well a link to your edit of episodes 1 and 2?