Now it's just getting ridiculous- Obi Wan's new howl. — Page 4

Maybe you should replace the howl with PT music.

vaderios said:

Asteroid-Man said:

There is one thing I'm excited to see: CG Yoda in TPM!!!

I'm also hoping for a more OT faithful CG Yoda render for the PT.

I hope for everything CG ;)

 

-Angel

Haha very funny. As anti-cg a lot of the OT posters are, I believe that it has only just recently gotten to a point where it can be seamlessly placed into a live action film - which does still leave some hope for the PT as they can now replace all of the TERRIBLE CG renders they used: Jar-Jar (let's be realistic - they won't delete him, the best they can do is not make him look like metallic plasticine), they could replace the Yoda renders with a more realistic one, and one that looks like the Yoda from ESB and ROTJ. I still have some small amount of hope that they'll get things right... if not in this release than dammit in the next release!!! Come on Lucasfilms, do SOMETHING right!

If they are going to change the audio so radical i suggest to make a seamless vader voice to all episodes :)

-Angel

It's not already seamless?

Akwat Kbrana said:

Maybe you should replace the howl with PT music.

 i take it your not a fan of post 1999 Star Wars JW?

Akwat Kbrana said:

Maybe you should replace the howl with PT music.

The Prequels got a fuck load of things wrong, but the PT music is simply amazing.

Seriously, I'm beginning to think some people on these forums are just hating all aspects of the PT simply because they're in some way related to the PT...

*sigh* No, I don't dislike the PT soundtracks. In fact, I consider the soundtracks of Ep. 1-3 to be a good deal superior to that of ep. 6. My comment was simply a sarcastic response to fishmanlee's:

i really think there should be NO howl

It was intended to be an amusing dig, given the fish's history of "rescoring."

changing music in a scene is one thing taking out a sound effect, thats something else

Akwat Kbrana said:

*sigh* No, I don't dislike the PT soundtracks. In fact, I consider the soundtracks of Ep. 1-3 to be a good deal superior to that of ep. 6. My comment was simply a sarcastic response to fishmanlee's:

i really think there should be NO howl

It was intended to be an amusing dig, given the fish's history of "rescoring."

Haha, alright, thank God. I was beginning to think you were trolling. :P

fishmanlee said:

changing music in a scene is one thing taking out a sound effect, thats something else

Asteroid-Man said:

There is one thing I'm excited to see: CG Yoda in TPM!!!

I'm also hoping for a more OT faithful CG Yoda render for the PT.

The sound mix was doomed from the beginning considering it is the same guy who did the 2004 mix.

The Blu Ray is doomed because it will be the bad 2004 versions with no fixes, changing the audio even further and making it worse does not equal a fix.

The Blu Ray probably will kill the bootleg HD market of the HDTV broadcasts and will be better with less compression. But it will still be from a master limited to 1080p, with messed up colors and DVNR.

If it is true the master files created in 2004 were thrown together in a quick turnaround with no quality control, i think the 2004 DVD was thrown together in 30 days or something.  Quite unlike Fox spending 20 million for a meticulous restoration, not done in the digital realm but photochemically, in 1997.

Lucash already had the work done but mucked it up.

Now that I see it again, the Episode I puppet really isn't so bad - especially when put side-to-side with that ESB shot. Everything's right but his eyes... oh, and the hair seems out of place. Ain't it funny how that works out?

That would be really out of place, though it IS quite creepy

doubleofive said:

 

There! for those who mentioned that yoda is only angry in PT. This is might the only photo from the Muppet gimmick that might give a reason for the ILMers to prove their efforts.

A-Man posted:

It's not already seamless?

No its not ;)

-Angel

doubleofive said:

 

Asteroid-Man said:

There is one thing I'm excited to see: CG Yoda in TPM!!!

I'm also hoping for a more OT faithful CG Yoda render for the PT.

I honestly think the PT Yoda model looks like a younger, more plump Yoda:



He has the same bone structure and just looks like he lost a lot of weight during the exile.

I know it's off topic, but it's kind of on.

 

Here's what I wanna see (I didn't make it)

VS

The PT Yoda model wasn't bad, but it wasn't great either.

What is the bad thing is the fact that he was made almost 10 years after Jurrassic Park.

In the end, he fits perfectly in George's cartoony CGI world, it is the "actors" who stick out like a sore thumb.

TV's Frink said:

How about Obi Wan using a Yoda howl?

I like the way you think, I'm gonna be watching you!!!

Oh?  Does Yoda howl during his iconic break dancing scene?  That definitely needs to be incorporated into the movies somehow.

My Eyes are burning.

The topic title is indeed "Now it's just getting ridiculous- Yoda's new CGI look."

Why this was gone offtopic about obiwan and about a weird howl? 

;)

-Berry