I went through the majority of the Universal classics...though it gets verry bad:
Dracula-Masterpiece with all of its flaws. 4/4
Spanish version-Better made in every way but drags on too long and is inferior sadly. 3/4
Frankenstein-Masterpiece. 4/4
Murders in the Rue Morgue-nothing to do with Poe, Lugosi is the only redeeming thing and is onscreen far too little, terrible monkey-suited man, and liberal doses of WTF. Terrible. 1.5/4
Island of Lost Souls-Poor version of Island of Dr. Moreau, with 90% of the novel gone for this cheapy 70 minute horror. Only Laughton's performance and the generated atmosphere are worthwhile. 2.5/4
The Mummy-Masterpiece. 4/4
The Old Dark House-I LOVE JIMMY WHALE. 4/4
The Invisible Man-Masterpiece. 4/4
The Black Cat-Obviously shorn to pieces by censors, made obvious by the ludicrous lack of plotting. Still it's Bela vs. Boris amidst supreme atmosphere, what's not to love? 3/4
The Raven-Mad ideas abound in this diabolically plotted picture that makes little to no sense. Bela and Boris are wonderful the rest is absolutely silly. 3/4
Werewolf of London-Absolutely dull and beyond silly. 1/4
Bride of Frankenstein-One of the great American films, one of the best films ever made, arguably the best picture of the 1930's, Whale's masterpiece, and easily by and large the greatest of all horror films. 4/4
Dracula's Daughter-Unbelievably dull and monotonous. A waste of everyone involved. 2.5/4
The Invisible Ray-Silly. 2/4
Night Key- Surprisingly effective crime thriller that has nothing to do with horror. Boris is wonderful. 3/4
Son of Frankenstein-Most underrated Universal horror. A great classic with Lugosi's best performance. 4/4
Tower of London-forgettable historical drama that is good only for basil Rathbone as Richard and an extremely young Vincent Price. 2.5/4
The Invisible Man Returns-Good plot setup but only middling to dull production. The beginning of the lesser budgeted cheapy horrors on tight economics courtesy of new studio owners. 3/4
The Invisible Woman-Good god, why make this a comedy? Abysmal. 1/4
The Mummy's Hand-The only good Mumym sequel, with plenty of humor and good ol' serial action. A true B-movie classic. 3.5/4
The Wolf Man-the least of the original monsters, because of plotting and low budgets, TWM excels in atmosphere and character portrayal with Lon Chaney Jr. truly nailing Talbot's accursed existence and Claude Rains performing as the screen's greatest supporting actor. 4/4
The Ghost of Frankenstein-Drivel. Pure and simple. Make it end. 2/4
Frankenstein Meets the Wolf Man-surprisingly good sequel to two different films that is good albeit obviously edited down to remove thew Creature's speech. 3/4
Phantom of the Opera (1943)-unnecessary beyond tepid remake of the silent classic where Claude Rains is horribly miscast as a more sympathetic Phantom. Make no mistake, this is merely a Technicpolor musical vehicle and not a horror film. Gorgeous to look at but not at all recommended. 1/4
Now time to finish off my hated Mummy sequels, then on to the rest of the 40's/40's output.
And speaking of the ongoing MoS debate and the horrid Supes movies that keep coming down the pipeline...I read this recently and felt it worked as a movie so well...http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_Son_%28comics%29