I've been on a Howard Hughes kick, because I am near where he was born, and am currently living in the city he was raised, so I thought I would watch as many movies and documentaries about them man as possible.
I chose 2 films that represent his life. What I will mostly judge them on is accuracy. While I think they are both great films, that's not the point.
The Aviator (2004)
Leonardo DiCaprio is the first real actor's actor we've had since Gary Oldman's early career. Martin Scorsese is for the most part, a great director. This film really succeeds thanks to these 2 men. Now for the accuracy. One could argue that Howard Hughes life is a mystery, and film can take certain liberties. While that might be the case for his life from 50's until his death, this film focuses on his early, in the press years. This film really shows him as being nutty early on, and fails to show the fact that he was rich before he ever lifted a hand. Instead, the film seems to suggest that he had to work to become wealthy, as he states later "You hate money, because you've always had it" Howard inherited a fortune when his father passed.
The Howard Hughes in this film pretty much starts out with a lot of his personality disorders. Sure, they do make note to amplify it after his last crash, but in real life that was what set off most of his problems. His germ phobia wasn't as bad as people made it out to be, he was leery of germs, but not to the extent the film showed. Now, after his last crash, he had serious issues with germs, and being touched. He was also in intense pain at all times.
The Amazing Howard Hughes (1977)
This film, starring Tommy Lee Jones, was made for television after Howard Hughes' death. It was made with help from long time assistant Noah Dietrich. Unlike The Aviator, this film spans Hughes' entire life. The first half is mostly like The Aviator, but it plays out more accurately. The only true problem it shows is his OCD. The second half focuses on his reclusive years, and what can be described as anybody's guess as to accuracy.
Tommy Lee Jones gives a brilliant performance, and manages to make you forget that it's him. What better person to play a Texan, than a Texan?
While this film wasn't shot as brilliantly as The Aviator, nor did it have the emotional impact either, it still has solid performances. The acting was amazing, and as much as I've researched on the man, I can't think of a casting decision that was bad. Whoever was playing Katherine Hepburn had her down perfectly.
This film also shows Hughes' personality decline at a more accurate pace.
Anybody who has seen The Aviator, should check this one out as well. It's Tommy Lee Jones for cryin' out loud. Appearance wise, he was perfect for the part. Dark hair, super tall, and southern.
Can't decide which is the best film, but the Tommy Lee Jones flick is a much better biography.