Info Wanted: Should ADYWAN re-edit the prequels? — Page 2

muddyknees2000 said:

I just dont think that the expectations that this will meet with the same success as Adywan's OT Revisited are all that realistic.

 Let's say that Ady's efforts result in a categorical increase in watchability equal to 'n'

ANH:SE x n = ANH:R

TPM x n = TPM:R

Just because ANH:SE > TPM and therefore ANH:R > TPM:R doesn't mean that TPM:R <\= TPM. 

I'll take a 'n' increase in the PT over those films as they stand anyday,  especially ROTS, which I don't think has ever had a great edit.

TheBoost said:

muddyknees2000 said:

I just dont think that the expectations that this will meet with the same success as Adywan's OT Revisited are all that realistic.

 Let's say that Ady's efforts result in a categorical increase in watchability equal to 'n'

ANH:SE x n = ANH:R

TPM x n = TPM:R

Just because ANH:SE > TPM and therefore ANH:R > TPM:R doesn't mean that TPM:R <\= TPM. 

I'll take a 'n' increase in the PT over those films as they stand anyday,  especially ROTS, which I don't think has ever had a great edit.

 yup, as I said....Revisited PT WILL be better.....I just have doubts that it can be made into something I would deem as "good" or "enjoyable". Although I just finished listening to a radio interview with Adywan on youtube (think it was quite old so not sure how much of this is still relevant) where he talks about making some MAJOR changes to the story. He only goes into detail about one of them, but its something I have complained about myself and agree with whole heartedly....so we will see

TheBoost said:

muddyknees2000 said:

I just dont think that the expectations that this will meet with the same success as Adywan's OT Revisited are all that realistic.

 Let's say that Ady's efforts result in a categorical increase in watchability equal to 'n'

ANH:SE x n = ANH:R

TPM x n = TPM:R

Just because ANH:SE > TPM and therefore ANH:R > TPM:R doesn't mean that TPM:R <\= TPM. 

Gerald Ford said:

It was my understanding that there would be no math.

How many of these sycophant Adywan threads do we need?

No, you're thinking of adywan.  This thread is for ADYWAN.

My bad?

Ye.

Can this thread now be about tuna sandwiches?

Might as well be.  If you read the OP, the question seems to be "Will ADYWAN re-edit the prequels?" and that's already been answered.

Now I'm hungry.

Well I know he's going to edit them, but I don't know about re-editing them.  I would think they will be good enugh after his first edit. 

So the thread is no longer about tuna sandwiches?  That's too bad.  I think it was more interesting back then.

I may have to do a fan edit of that recipe.

Oooh...I'd love to see a mockup.

I need to wait till I get home with the photoshop before I can make an ACTUAL MOVIE SEQUENCE

Just don't forget the salt and pepper for the older kids.  I know you think it wasn't in the Original Original Sandwich but THE MEMORY CHEATS.

lol!

lol!