logo Sign In

At what age did you realize that Star Wars isn't a documentary?

Author
Time

If feels like Star Wars has always been a part of my consciousness. I can’t remember the first time I saw it, and I can’t remember if I already knew that spoiler was Luke’s father, or if I got to experience that twist properly. In fact, I was so young when I fell in love with Star Wars, I didn’t even completely understand the concept of movies. The notion that regular people got dressed up and read lines off a script hadn’t formed in my head yet. As far as I was concerned, a film crew went to Tatooine and shot the movie, then came back and here it was. For all I knew, Star Wars was a documentary.

The first film in the series that I saw was Phantom Menace and, like I assume many of you did as well, I loved it at the time. I thought Anakin was cool and Jar Jar was funny. I even remember laughing out loud the first time I saw Ben and Vader’s duel at the end of New Hope. I have a drastically different perspective on the series now, of course, but the sound effects and the aesthetic still give me flash backs when I scroll past Phantom Menace on TV.

It was watching the behind-the-scenes features on the dvd though, that really shattered my world. I couldn’t believe my eyes. Mace Windu was just some guy? Qui-Gon Jinn was just a dude playing dress up? It’s all fake? Remember, this wasn’t when I was 15. I must have been around 4. Memories warp with time, and I can’t remember if it was something I honestly believed, or something I wanted to be true so badly I ignored the common sense in the back of my mind telling me I was wrong. But I vividly remember a strong feeling of disappointment when one day I decided to to hit “bonus features” instead of “play movie”.

I hope I’m lucky enough to get a myspleen invite one day so I can put the Despecialized Editions on Blu-ray. I have two Nieces, three and five, and I want them to get the proper experience. But I’m not sure if I want to wait to show them when they’re old enough to appreciate it, or if I should show them as early as possible. Empire I’ll probably hold off on, so they don’t see I Am Your Father until they’re old enough to know what it means. But New Hope at least, I kind of want to become part of their subconscious. Even if they’ll never remember their first time watching it, I kind of want them to know what Star Wars is before they know what movies are, so maybe they can get that same moment realization and say “wait a second, this isn’t real”?

Author
Time

Every day I think I can’t possibly feel older…and then I read something like this.

Author
Time

I mean, I’m pretty young, but I’m pretty sure I at least understood the difference between fiction and reality when I first saw Star Wars, and I couldn’t have been much older than you were when you describe having your realization.

.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Interesting. I’m in that camp too where I never got that “shock” moment when Vader said he was Luke’s father; it’s akin to asking me when I learned what the color red was and how I felt. I don’t remember, I just know. Where we differ though in respect to OP is that I don’t quite remember feeling like it was a documentary. I knew it was a fantasy. What made me concious that these films were movies was probably due to seeing some specials on TV (I think one was called Empire of Dreams…?) and those programs would show some behind the scene stuff. That really sparked the imagination in me and even now, I dream of becoming a film director of sorts, and it’s all because of Star Wars, knowing how it was made was really exciting to me just as much as watching the films.

Side note, though I’ve mentioned it before, it’s funny to me how I must be in the minority that really found TPM super boring despite seeing it at age 4.

The Rise of Failures

Author
Time

TavorX said:

Side note, though I’ve mentioned it before, it’s funny to me how I must be in the minority that really found TPM super boring despite seeing it at age 4.

I just found it to be confusing. And I was six when I first saw it.

A lot people tend to retroactively forget that the prequels never actually explain anything lore-wise. It just kind of expects you to already know, which is weird when your target audience is kids. Especially since I, like many people here, and most people born after ca. 1990 in general, was intentionally exposed to “Episode I” first.
(I guess I’m lucky that AOTC and ROTS hadn’t come out yet, as I had a much easier time getting into the OT as it was more coherent.)


I can’t remember ever thinking movies were real, I was just really blown away when I found out just exactly how much of it was fake and how they did it. (However, I do remember that at age four I believed all TV was done live because of sitcoms.)

Star Wars is Surrealism, not Science Fiction (essay)
Original Trilogy Documentaries/Making-Ofs (YouTube, Vimeo, etc. finds)
Beyond the OT Documentaries/Making-Ofs (YouTube, Vimeo, etc. finds)
Amazon link to my novel; Dawn of the Karabu.

Author
Time

I think I’ve always understood they are fiction. I first saw the OT in theaters when I was about 7 so I had somewhat of an understanding of what was going on. I don’t remember how I felt when I found out about Vader being Luke’s father.

Author
Time

Wait! The Star Wars movies didn’t happen?! Why didn’t anyone tell me?!

Not enough people read the EU.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Once upon a time I had a Ric Olie sock who pretended that TPM was a documentary and he was the real-life hero of it.

He also pretended he was super handsome.

[sobs]

Author
Time

I don’t know like never? What’s this thread about? If you can follow a movie plot then surely you know what a movie is.