Fan made David Lynch's Return of the Jedi trailer edit

In 1981 George Lucas offered the director's chair to David Lynch. But Lynch was not a sci-fi fan, so, he refused.

Now, a fan made trailer showing us what could have been...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PALjbTo1D5U&feature=youtu.be

Please share you're thoughts below.

My thought: there are several existing threads you could have posted this in.

Sorry...

But now its here, share you're thoughts.

Besides, a link to that video has been posted already. *whistle*

Aren't we a cantankerous bunch.

Cantankerous? Moi? Impossible*!

*Please read in French accent for optimal effect.

Kosh Naranek says :

**

Sorry.

I pay more attenction next time.

Could be worse...he could have gone on the  Off Topic boards.

I like the trailer I've seen others like it but it's probably the best so far, I would like to see someone do a whole film edit where Lynchian motifs were added but in a less obviously pastiche way.

The strobing Palpatine is in my opinion genuinely disturbing stuff.

bkev said:

Wow guys.  Way to needlessly gang up on a new guy who felt a video was worth its own thread.  Sheesh.

David Lynch should never appear in the title of a thread that doesn't include "I Hate."

TV's Frink said:

bkev said:

Wow guys.  Way to needlessly gang up on a new guy who felt a video was worth its own thread.  Sheesh.

David Lynch should never appear in the title of a thread that doesn't include "I Hate."

 My thought: there is at least one existing thread you could have posted that in :-P

Well now I have to go make a new thread about it.

TV's Frink said:

bkev said:

Wow guys.  Way to needlessly gang up on a new guy who felt a video was worth its own thread.  Sheesh.

David Lynch should never appear in the title of a thread that doesn't include "I Hate."

You should be trapped in the Black Lodge for uttering such blasphemy. 

How do you search for old threads anyway?

I don't see a search engine widget on the forum page...

EDIT: Based on the "Feature Request" forum, it was removed.

So how are you going to fault this guy for not digging up an old thread?  In fact, doesn't this mean that once a thread falls off page 1, a new thread HAS to be started on that topic or else the user has to go page by page through the whole history in hopes that there MIGHT be a preexisting relevant topic?

We had a search function but it never worked properly I just add "site:originaltrilogy.com" to the end of a google search on whatever subject I'm looking up but I do also have a very good memory for old threads.

Bingowings said:

We had a search function but it never worked properly I just add "site:originaltrilogy.com" to the end of a google search on whatever subject I'm looking up but I do also have a very good memory for old threads.

 Even if you have a great memory for old threads, you still need to search for them to locate which page they're on...

Ergo the solution I mentioned in the post you quote.

If you were to want to find out if there was a thread about Super Nintendo Super Star Wars you could try typing "SNES Super Star Wars site:originaltrilogy.com" into google and you would get...

Darth Id said:

So how are you going to fault this guy for not digging up an old thread?  In fact, doesn't this mean that once a thread falls off page 1, a new thread HAS to be started on that topic or else the user has to go page by page through the whole history in hopes that there MIGHT be a preexisting relevant topic?

 The two most relevant threads were on page one.

imperialscum said:

TV's Frink, for example, is a known troll

http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Guidelines-for-Post-Content-and-General-Behavior-Or-How-Not-To-Get-Banned/forum/2/topic/12074/

No personal attacks.

To help you avoid getting banned, I'll help you fix your post.

imperialscum said:

TV's Frink, for example, is a known and respected member of the community who has contributed in many ways and is always willing to help out anyone who doesn't take themselves or this place too seriously.  In fact, he previously helped out the OP just one day prior to this thread being made.