General Star Wars Random Thoughts Thread — Page 56

buddy-x-wing said:

SilverWook said:

I could never figure out why Lucas didn't restore Red Leader's dialog in the SE about having met Luke's father when he was younger, and that he was a "great pilot". It doesn't seem to contradict anything in the prequels.

although unless Red Leader was a Clone pilot or a Jedi or one of those pilots from Naboo, how would he know that Anakin was a good pilot?  although I'm only using the prequels as a point of reference, perhaps they'll retcon red leader into a Clone Wars episode now that I've said that.

Could be he flew for some planetary defense force similar to Naboo's. Likely the route The Clone Wars would take if they do so.

I'd actually like to see that, come to think of it.

Yeah, there's been quite a few episodes where the Republic (and especially the Jedi) helps some planetary defense force. It'd just be cool to see if they handle Red Leader.

The EU, has (obviously) already handled the reference, but I'd like to see what Filoni and co. could do with it.

SilverWook said:

buddy-x-wing said:

SilverWook said:

I could never figure out why Lucas didn't restore Red Leader's dialog in the SE about having met Luke's father when he was younger, and that he was a "great pilot". It doesn't seem to contradict anything in the prequels.

although unless Red Leader was a Clone pilot or a Jedi or one of those pilots from Naboo, how would he know that Anakin was a good pilot?  although I'm only using the prequels as a point of reference, perhaps they'll retcon red leader into a Clone Wars episode now that I've said that.

He could have simply been a witness to some daring do Anakin performed during the Clone Wars. Ordinary people have crossed paths with heroes in real life throughout history.

It always felt to me like they'd flown together, though.

Stand by.

This board has gone stupid with all the "What if...?" threads.

I agree. Counter-trolling is not going to do anything but junk up the forum more than it already has been until it's just unbearable for everyone.

Additionally it makes it harder for new members to realize that their threads need improvement.

What is the deal with all the troll threads? What started them?

Just reading the titles tires me out.

I think they were started to poke fun at Father Skywalker's hypothetical situations and "what if" scenarios in regards to Moff Jerjerrod surviving the Death Star's explosion and Darth Vader's apparent enlightened dictatorship had the Emperor not been around.

SilverWook said:

Lucky you! I have to read what's in them! ;)

If I were you I'd just delete them all "with extreme prejudice."

So, as SpilkaBilka noted here:http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/TPM-and-AotC-colour-correction/topic/14532/page/5/

The guy in the back:

and middle-left guy:

Mind = blown.

Because the Star Wars fanbase needs some more division...

I agree. I had no idea that there were people who would think that the 501st isn't a good organization, or that this is somehow a result of Disney's purchase of Lucasfilm.

Ugh.

I don't want to give anyone any ideas, but why don't they make a Max Rebo Band version of This is Spinal Tap?

We would all watch that!!!!

That would actually be pretty awesome, but it would have to be the original rubber puppets or no dice :-D