Finally managed to finish off watching this a few days ago.
(I typed that, then went looking and found this post of mine from 4 years ago - history repeating itself!)
I have to say that SWB is a fantasticallyy compelling watch. I think the reason that it has attracted so much more internet attention than BE and RtJ is that there is just so much more rare behind-the-scenes stuff out there for the original Star Wars. (What other film could spark a debate about the voice of a character who only appears in 2 scenes?)
I think your choice of commentaries is faultless. I'm normally indifferent to audio commentaries on DVD and rarely listen to them, but I loved the audio clips on SWB. Mark Hamill's stuff about mating ladybugs and comparing himself to a plump juicy raisin is wonderful, and - as he says - "that's the sort of thing you don't normally hear about in a making-of documentary".
It's also intersting to hear the respect that the cast had for Alec Guinness, and Guinness's admiration of George Lucas. After constantly reading Lucas-bashing posts on this site, it's refreshing to hear his early speeches about his struggle to get the film made, and to find yourself actually liking the guy.
If you ever consider doing a V3, there are a couple of improvements I would suggest:
- I found that the speech balloons on the Chief Bast scene move around too much to be legible
- it sounds like you used a lower-quality recording of the mono mix, instead of the restored version I sent you way back at the start of the project (maybe you lost it in the hard drive crash? I'll gladly send it you again).
One final question...
What do we have to do to convince you to take on that Raiders project you hinted at? ;-)