STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW — Page 509

It's been tough to find things that bother me about ESB, knowing the majority of them are being fixed. I've made many suggestions in this thread (some rejected, some supported), and after all this time, my idea well is running more and more dry!

But... here is one thing I've been meaning to mention for a while, and just kept forgetting to do for some reason... toward the end of the asteroid chase, just before Han finds the asteroid cave, he says "there, that looks pretty good." While he says this line, he points out the cockpit with his finger, implying he VISUALLY spotted it with nothing but the eyes he was born with...

... yet in the next shot, while Leia is asking "what looks pretty good?", the view outside of the cockpit is very clearly NOT showing a cave yet! As they continue flying, only then does the cave appear. How could Han have known there was a cave there? For all he knew, it could have just been another valley!

A fix could be just replacing the footage outside the front of the cockpit to show what Han is talking about, maybe making the cave appear a lot sooner, or making the valley bigger so that they are already flying into it when Leia says the line. Otherwise, it is just illogical to see how Han spotted a cave that he couldn't possibly have seen yet, as he kept the Falcon flying low the entire time.

"What looks pretty good?" Indeed.

Darth Solo said: I have loads of trouble taking each individual hair off my face every few days. 

I can imagine! Most guys generally just shave the beard/mustache area, not the whole face! ;)

Heh heh... I love that little green guy. Lookit him go!

Darth Solo said:

Ripplin said:

Darth Solo said: I have loads of trouble taking each individual hair off my face every few days. 

I can imagine! Most guys generally just shave the beard/mustache area, not the whole face! ;)

 

 

OK you cracked me up on that one. Im not a mexican wolf boy. ALA Bo in USA. Although some parts of my body, erm...(spread like wild fire!). Thats why i wear these red robes, but even then a few tufts of hair stick out.

What the hell am i going on about? (looks like a bad day to lay off the crystal meth i guess)

See, even the popcorn head has a scence of humour at times.

Try having a back that would make chewbacca freak out. ARRRRRRRRRRRFFFFF

adywan said:

focuspuller said:

Don't slap me for saying this, how do I donate again? I did it before but I don't remember. A paypal link right?

yeh, it's through paypal:

adywan(at)hotmail(dot)co(dot)uk

(changing the sections in brackets for the correct characters)

 

pm sent

oh_riginal said:

It's been tough to find things that bother me about ESB, knowing the majority of them are being fixed. I've made many suggestions in this thread (some rejected, some supported), and after all this time, my idea well is running more and more dry!

But... here is one thing I've been meaning to mention for a while, and just kept forgetting to do for some reason... toward the end of the asteroid chase, just before Han finds the asteroid cave, he says "there, that looks pretty good." While he says this line, he points out the cockpit with his finger, implying he VISUALLY spotted it with nothing but the eyes he was born with...

... yet in the next shot, while Leia is asking "what looks pretty good?", the view outside of the cockpit is very clearly NOT showing a cave yet! As they continue flying, only then does the cave appear. How could Han have known there was a cave there? For all he knew, it could have just been another valley!

A fix could be just replacing the footage outside the front of the cockpit to show what Han is talking about, maybe making the cave appear a lot sooner, or making the valley bigger so that they are already flying into it when Leia says the line. Otherwise, it is just illogical to see how Han spotted a cave that he couldn't possibly have seen yet, as he kept the Falcon flying low the entire time.

"What looks pretty good?" Indeed.

 um he was saying it about the "ASTEROID" it self

fishmanlee said:

oh_riginal said:

It's been tough to find things that bother me about ESB, knowing the majority of them are being fixed. I've made many suggestions in this thread (some rejected, some supported), and after all this time, my idea well is running more and more dry!

But... here is one thing I've been meaning to mention for a while, and just kept forgetting to do for some reason... toward the end of the asteroid chase, just before Han finds the asteroid cave, he says "there, that looks pretty good." While he says this line, he points out the cockpit with his finger, implying he VISUALLY spotted it with nothing but the eyes he was born with...

... yet in the next shot, while Leia is asking "what looks pretty good?", the view outside of the cockpit is very clearly NOT showing a cave yet! As they continue flying, only then does the cave appear. How could Han have known there was a cave there? For all he knew, it could have just been another valley!

A fix could be just replacing the footage outside the front of the cockpit to show what Han is talking about, maybe making the cave appear a lot sooner, or making the valley bigger so that they are already flying into it when Leia says the line. Otherwise, it is just illogical to see how Han spotted a cave that he couldn't possibly have seen yet, as he kept the Falcon flying low the entire time.

"What looks pretty good?" Indeed.

 um he was saying it about the "ASTEROID" it self

Why would he randomly point out the asteroid they've been flying over for a minute or so already (they lose the TIEs in a canyon on the same asteroid where he points out the cave no one can see yet)?

alright i just watched that point, i think hes talking about the crater that cave/s are in prehaps asteroids craters are renowned for their caves?

doubleofive said:

fishmanlee said:

oh_riginal said:

It's been tough to find things that bother me about ESB, knowing the majority of them are being fixed. I've made many suggestions in this thread (some rejected, some supported), and after all this time, my idea well is running more and more dry!

But... here is one thing I've been meaning to mention for a while, and just kept forgetting to do for some reason... toward the end of the asteroid chase, just before Han finds the asteroid cave, he says "there, that looks pretty good." While he says this line, he points out the cockpit with his finger, implying he VISUALLY spotted it with nothing but the eyes he was born with...

... yet in the next shot, while Leia is asking "what looks pretty good?", the view outside of the cockpit is very clearly NOT showing a cave yet! As they continue flying, only then does the cave appear. How could Han have known there was a cave there? For all he knew, it could have just been another valley!

A fix could be just replacing the footage outside the front of the cockpit to show what Han is talking about, maybe making the cave appear a lot sooner, or making the valley bigger so that they are already flying into it when Leia says the line. Otherwise, it is just illogical to see how Han spotted a cave that he couldn't possibly have seen yet, as he kept the Falcon flying low the entire time.

"What looks pretty good?" Indeed.

 um he was saying it about the "ASTEROID" it self

Why would he randomly point out the asteroid they've been flying over for a minute or so already (they lose the TIEs in a canyon on the same asteroid where he points out the cave no one can see yet)?

To be fair I point out sidewalks that I've been walking on for over a minute and say "that looks pretty good" all the time. Then when I reach the edge of the curb I notice a pothole before I see it. It's awesome!

All kidding aside, this is one error in the movie I'd love to see fixed. A mock-up for this may be too difficult for me to pull off, so I don't think I'll be taking a stab at it, unfortunately.

Histeria said:

oh_riginal said:

doubleofive said:

fishmanlee said:

oh_riginal said:

It's been tough to find things that bother me about ESB, knowing the majority of them are being fixed. I've made many suggestions in this thread (some rejected, some supported), and after all this time, my idea well is running more and more dry!

But... here is one thing I've been meaning to mention for a while, and just kept forgetting to do for some reason... toward the end of the asteroid chase, just before Han finds the asteroid cave, he says "there, that looks pretty good." While he says this line, he points out the cockpit with his finger, implying he VISUALLY spotted it with nothing but the eyes he was born with...

... yet in the next shot, while Leia is asking "what looks pretty good?", the view outside of the cockpit is very clearly NOT showing a cave yet! As they continue flying, only then does the cave appear. How could Han have known there was a cave there? For all he knew, it could have just been another valley!

A fix could be just replacing the footage outside the front of the cockpit to show what Han is talking about, maybe making the cave appear a lot sooner, or making the valley bigger so that they are already flying into it when Leia says the line. Otherwise, it is just illogical to see how Han spotted a cave that he couldn't possibly have seen yet, as he kept the Falcon flying low the entire time.

"What looks pretty good?" Indeed.

 um he was saying it about the "ASTEROID" it self

Why would he randomly point out the asteroid they've been flying over for a minute or so already (they lose the TIEs in a canyon on the same asteroid where he points out the cave no one can see yet)?

 

 

To be fair I point out sidewalks that I've been walking on for over a minute and say "that looks pretty good" all the time. Then when I reach the edge of the curb I notice a pothole before I see it. It's awesome!

All kidding aside, this is one error in the movie I'd love to see fixed. A mock-up for this may be too difficult for me to pull off, so I don't think I'll be taking a stab at it, unfortunately.

 

I'd always assumed that the Falcon's sensors (which Han was looking at and Leia wasn't) had picked up the 'cave' before it it could be seen from the cockpit.

 

I thought maybe this was the case too, and rewatched the scene last night. It looks like his hand is too high to be pointing at any screens or gadgets on the dashboard. It looks more like he is pointing out the cockpit window.

Well, if the sensors tell him where it is, that's reasonable. He'd be looking out the window, trying to see what he's been told is there, not pointing it out on the console. He's talking almost to himself, or maybe just to Chewbacca.

RoccondilRinon said:

Well, if the sensors tell him where it is, that's reasonable. He'd be looking out the window, trying to see what he's been told is there, not pointing it out on the console. He's talking almost to himself, or maybe just to Chewbacca.

I don't know, that seems to be a stretch. If it were me flying, and I saw a cave on the sensor, I'd be pointing at the sensor while saying that, instead of pointing out the window when I still can't see it with my own eyes. Just saying....

As you can see here, neither Han's eyes OR his finger is pointing anywhere on the dashboard, implying he is looking out the front view of the cockpit, as if something is in front of the ship... in this case, a cave entrance.

"That looks pretty good...."

"What looks pretty good?"

Indeed! What the hell is Han pointing at? Clearly the screen is black on the monitor, so there isn't any sensors on obviously. The cave is still a distance further, inside that valley up ahead. How could Han possibly know a cave is there??

"Excuse me, ma'am, but where are we going?"

Into a cave that Han used the force to predict would be there, apparently!

Solution? As I mentioned before, maybe changing the view outside the cockpit to match what the characters are supposed to be seeing.

I suppose one could also turn the sensor on in this shot, but it would be so small that it wouldn't really make the average movie viewer understand why it is on, since the screen would only be visible for a brief moment (not to mention that Leia would block it quickly when she stood up). The only way this would work would be to add a close-up of the monitor, and I know from personal experience that there is simply no hi-res close-ups of the monitor to be found for a proper mock-up... and oh, how I wish there were, as a few of you may recall.....

We can assume that the sensors are on, and as I said, he's talking almost to himself. You could put a radar display on the screen or something if you want to make that clear, which would probably be easier than changing the scene outside.

Alternatively, you can interpret the line "That looks pretty good" to refer to the crater, in which he maybe hopes to find somewhere to hide, and "Yeah, that'll do nicely" to refer to the cave when he sees it.

^What are you saying? Ferry is spelled wrong? ;)