logo Sign In

Info: Is this site cool with "fanedit.org?"

This topic has been locked by a moderator.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

I ask because I was “banned” by fanedit.org after I reviewed an edit, approved it, and then one of the “higher ups” reviewed it and said it was no good and I was denied the right to review any other fan edit.

Then, all hell broke loose and they banned me. Plus, Boon23 had me banned from Link Talk after I paid my $15 to access it since I disagreed with him and didn’t want any of my fan edits posted on his site… . Unfortunately now I have to report them since they took my money and closed my account on Link Talk because of the issue with Boon.

I’m completely “down” with fanedits, I can search them out on my own and don’t agree with posting any links but I love to talk about them. And I generally don’t like reporting websites or people to the MPAA (I’m no snitch), but when they take my money, they’re crossing the line.

Anyway, I’m glad to see there’s another site to talk about edits. That fanedit.org place is the very definition of shady.

Take it easy guys.

Author
Time

if this is "superman4thefinalcut" than you had a banning coming to you WAY BEFORE you were banned.

 

my advice is this: DO NOT mess up your time here at the OT forums as well.

Author
Time

For the record, FE didn't take your money - you spent it yourself in order to download from RS at a faster rate than a standard member (which would've been free for you, but taken longer to get all the files).

Your review was voided because another member found that the fanedit under review had too many technical flaws to be approved for posting on the main FE site.

As for you're banning, considering the fact that:
- you displayed very little appreciation or interest in fixing the technical issues that plagued some of your edits and that you insulted people when they suggested otherwise
- you argued and insulted other members that they were too "narrow-minded" to get what you were trying to accomplish and that they should just accept your "vision" no matter how many technical issues/flaws were in the movie, just because you say that it's "better" than the original version
- you hijacked another member's thread in order to further complain and accuse members of "playing favorites" with certain edits and to further argue about the disapproval of one of your edits (despite being repeatedly warned by the mods)

Well, I'm not suprised that you were banned from the site.

Author
Time

Please don't bring fanedit.org drama over here.

Guidelines for post content and general behaviour: read announcement here

Max. allowable image sizes in signatures: reminder here