logo Sign In

Color Grading/Correcting

Author
Time
As sort of a hobby I've been working on a custom DVD set of the classic French films "Jean de Florette" and "Manon des Sources". After reading a thread in the Fan Edits page about color-correcting Lord of the Rings, I became interested in doing the same thing with these movies.

If you don't know, these two 1986 French films comprise one story, which revolves around a disasterous scheme of two farmers to steal their neighbor's land in 1930's Provence. Sounds simple, but they're really amazing films, with classic performances from some fo the best French actors of our time.

Sadly, they've never received a proper DVD treatment, least of all in the U.S. The subtitles paraphrase at best and mangle at worst., and the recent R1 release, while anamorphic and crisp, has an awful color grade. If the various editions were compiled, given a top-notch translation, and color-corrected, it could really be something. So that's my project, in a nutshell.

I'm a graphic designer with a good grasp of color theory. Is it feasible that if I purchased Vegas I could apply some simple color-correcting to these movies? Is this the kind of thing someone could tackle with a little bit of help from you guys? All I want to do is tone down a golden cast throughout the film.

Old R1 release:
http://img300.imageshack.us/img300/3764/jdf1vf3.jpg

New R1 release:
http://img153.imageshack.us/img153/4323/jdf2sa2.jpg

My Photoshop approximation of what I want:
http://img149.imageshack.us/img149/3056/jdf3ki2.jpg

The top print is too grainy and washed out. The new print looks great, good clarity, except for a heavy emphasis on reds and yellows. It gives the whole film a gold look which does suit the languid and old-fashioned feel of the movies, but it's a bit much. In the carnation blossoms seen all throughout the movies, the reds are blooming in the worst way - pun intended. I'd like to make the color wash a bit more subtle, which is what I've tried to do with the third image. It approximates the more natural look I'm going for while still hanging on to the most subtle skew toward the warmer tones.

If you visit http://www.dvdbeaver.com/film/DVDCompare/jeandeflorette.htm you can see what I'm talking about. Scroll down until you hit the comparison screen caps.

Any help or guidance would be greatly appreciated!

Author
Time
I'm not sure about Vegas as I haven't used it myself, but both After Effects and Adobe Premiere Pro 2.0 have color-correcting effects. I haven't messed around with After Effects' color-correction, but Premiere's is quite extensive.

Best of luck! Sounds like a cool project. I like the look of your Photoshop representation.
Author
Time
Free alternatives also exist - there are filters for making colour adjustments in AviSynth or VirtualDub. Might be worth trying out these first before spending money.

Guidelines for post content and general behaviour: read announcement here

Max. allowable image sizes in signatures: reminder here

Author
Time
Thanks guys! I'll be sure to check those out and report back here with results!
Author
Time
Looking at the images above - yes the old release is grainy and washed out, but it does seem to contain more detail than the new release (look at the branches agasint the sky).

I don't know whether that's because the new release has an increased contrast which has "blown out" the sky, or whether it's been smoothed to reduce grain. (Or if it's something to do with resizing the screenshots.)

If the screenshots are representative, then best results might be obtained by running the old video through an AviSynth script with degrain filter and colour saturation boost.

Guidelines for post content and general behaviour: read announcement here

Max. allowable image sizes in signatures: reminder here

Author
Time
yes Moth3r, it's true that the original R1 does seem to contain some additional detail. I think you're right, the new release has been contrast boosted and smothered, and consequently the sky is blown out, which is unfortunate, because you lose some subtle wispy clouds in many shots. However, it's exceedingly grainy and dark. Plus, if you look at the right edge, you'll see the new release contains a bit more of the image, which I would like to keep since it makes a difference in some scenes.

I'd like to at least try an avisynth script on the original R1. Is there anywhere I can get scripts for degrain and saturation boost?
Author
Time
There are dozens of good grain reduction filters for AviSynth. You will find lots of information at Doom9.org, but it might seem a little daunting at first.

My current favourite is MVDegrain2 (as discussed in this thread).

Colour saturation is easily adjusted by the internal filter Tweak(). If you want an easy to use GUI, I recommend AvsP.

List of stuff to download:
AviSynth (obviously)
DGMPGDec package (for reading MPEG-2 video into AviSynth)
MVTools (contains the above mentioned grain filter)
AvsP (for previewing scripts and adjusting parameters)

Guidelines for post content and general behaviour: read announcement here

Max. allowable image sizes in signatures: reminder here