One thing George forgot …not all poetry rhymes , nor does it have to .
100%.
As Emre says above there are some good points and facts made in Plinkett’s section on George, rhyming, Ring Theory and more, in his TFA review: https://youtu.be/miVRaoR_8xQ?t=653
Not forgetting his actual reviews on the Prequels themselves.
Contrary to what some other believe and claim, I even managed to still have my own views on the PT films after watching the Plinkett reviews!
In case it gets lost in the shuffle , I will repost the video by Hellogreedo here , which critiques the whole "ring theory " in a manner of civil discourse that is far removed from the tone of Plinkett …https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1FGBGcvWkdM and how was it that George described poetry ? Oh , yeah , now I remember …https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yFqFLo_bYq0
Quality, thank you for posting those.
That’s just like , uh , you’re opinion . Dude , you are literally commenting on a forum which was created with the expressed purpose of preserving his original vision , as well as that of his numerous collaborators who helped bring that vision to life and who’s work is sadly swept under the rug in favor of his numerous revisions …like those commentaries you mentioned . Kasdan not withstanding ,as those were snippets culled from other interviews . I don’t need a video ,or you , to tell me "how to watch Star Wars " , I know how to watch Star Wars , I load the tape into my VCR ,The disc into my DVD player or cue up some of the wonderful preservations created here .
You’re wasting your time friend. Stardust is a Lucas zealot. Almost everything he posts is in praise of George, and how others who don’t like his films simply don’t understand or misunderstand him, the Prequels, or his supposed “vision”. If something is critical of George or the Prequels then Stardust is going to shit on it and give more links for videos and content he does approve of (pro-George or pro-Prequel content). He has no respect for this forum, the people here, or what they say in conversations, and has already insulted others on here. He is not posting in good faith, and cannot bring himself to admit when he is wrong, or when caught out when making false claims, or apologize to others. Stardust often talks about growing and learning, but is not willing to do that himself. He is basically trolling.
Stardust completely made a fool of himself completely misunderstanding a post by ken-obi yesterday, and couldn’t even bring himself to simply apologize for it. Instead he tried to portray himself as a victim. Sparkysywer saw through it here: https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/Unpopular-Opinion-Thread/id/80996/page/22#1479909
I’d just ignore Stardust, until he leaves, or the mods ban him for trolling and shitting on this place, and the users here.
Countless Prequel fans are on here, or people who simply appreciate the Prequels, or who like and respect George, all get on fine with everyone and there is no problem. These are the people worth talking with, to me anyway.