You’re making suggestions.
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress
Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress
well not really I am thinking about missing detail on those shots. It’s more about trying to have a much better version which we do now have already.
With that said I have never tried it myself I assume you need to blend 50/50 2 sources and color match or mask in or something. I don’t know how to do this but I assume that is how you would do that sort of repair. And possibly it being relatively simple task.
You’re making suggestions.
Yes, the crushed blacks on the bluray are terrible and unfortunate.
But ESB:R is finished. If you wanna talk about editing this edit, I suggest making your own thread. Otherwise you’re being very obnoxious.
Stumbled on a couple ESB:R reviews on youtube-
It’s like Ronster doesn’t understand that words mean things.
If people keep making suggestions this edit will never get finished.
I blame adywan. The thread title used to tell people to not make anymore suggestions, but now that it says the edit is available, people are free to make more suggestions.
Stumbled on a couple ESB:R reviews on youtube-
Thanks for the heads up on these!
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress
Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress
If people are so intent on making suggestions or pointing out errors to an edit that’s already been verified as finished, then why don’t they just create their own version in attempting to change/fix these things?
I myself personally would hate to edit this version because I would just feel so bad even if I did it in secret or my own personal version no way hose.
I think Ady should move on and I should stop thinking about this film. Even if there are a few things and if ever I do an edit of this film I will never use this version god I would feel like such a thief even if Ady gave me permission which I doubt would happen… lol. I hope Ady can adopt a version approach perhaps at later point more like a continued improvement approach perhaps similar to de-specialized although I have to admit I never watched or downloaded them. they do look good though and I know I should check them out but i see certain things I know are not right and although I love the original films they try to recreate without any common sense fixes which is ok but not taking into account the plethora of why, who, what, where and when it’s not even about special effects or continuity errors but perhaps just trying to get to the bottom of it all with this film which is brilliant but also a bit curio compared to star wars.
I no way intend to be obnoxious that is very harsh because I love what Ady did I just want it to be always a bit better if possible and I think we all want that so don’t bring the hammer down on me. There is no complaints but I could list around 35 things I would love to do or try at least…one day but I would never steal from ady man no way.
I posted a thread about black crush and blown highlights I will be doing some experiments. I might use revisted as a source but it won’t be for anything other than benefit of the film and probably in stills not video.
This is very much based on there is nothing to lose if there is nothing there…
Luma key is perhaps another option.
I think Ady should move on and I should stop thinking about this film.
He is.
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress
Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress
I think Ady should move on and I should stop thinking about this film.
He is.
I can’t believe you read that far.
I think Ady should move on and I should stop thinking about this film.
He is.
I can’t believe you read that far.
I did stop reading after that.
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress
Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress
In case you missed it:
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress
Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress
Ady, there’s some funky low-frequency color noise in the background of the shot at 00:24:35.
I noticed it when watching on my projector and it was a lot more visible there than it is now on my monitor but it’s still there and it took me right out of the movie.
The artifacts are likely to have already been there in the BD but they were brought out when you added a more yellow glow from the sun.
A simple low-frequency denoise pass should solve it nicely without affecting the overall detail. I have some great tools for this, so if you send me an uncompressed version of that shot, I’d be happy to give it a go for you 😃
Thanks Harmy. Checked the project file and there was an extra layer that was enabled at low opacity. re-rendered that and it seems fine now. And the clouds you mentioned, it is HD footage but seems that changing the colour brought out this effect. I’ve done what you said and added a slight blur. Thanks again 😃
Happy to help 😃
Is there and ETA for the bluray version? It sounded like the BTS feature wasn’t quite started yet, so I imagine it’ll be awhile. Just wondering.
I’m sure “when it’s done” will be the mantra for all the projects.
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress
Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress
Ady, at 30:07 - 30:10 there is a white object halfway up the extreme left of frame. It moves slightly as if it was a stop-motion element at some stage.
Is that supposed to be there?
They told me they’d fixed it!
The Revisited Twitter Account just asked a question and I think I found the answer.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6gREnJQlm9GOWExYV9sdnkzLXM/view?usp=sharing
The Revisited Twitter Account just asked a question and I think I found the answer.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6gREnJQlm9GOWExYV9sdnkzLXM/view?usp=sharing
That was my guess. It’s a bit more evident when in motion.
They told me they’d fixed it!
Why was Clive Revill’s name in the credits, when he wasn’t even in this version?
Because he’s in the SE credits even though he’s not in it any more.
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress
Star Wars Visual Comparisons WordPress
Respect? I dunno. I’ve heard that he’s still in the official SE credits, too.
JEDIT: 005 beat me.