Hal 9000

Right, I can’t really break that down into a logical reason other than that it just feels wrong to me.

I don’t mean to sound dismissive, but I don’t think that that awesome trailer music feels right in the context of the movie itself at all.

Eh, I’m willing to just wait as long as ends up being needed for this angle to be worked out and put out an alternate version. I might even go for it on some viewings.

I just do the entire fan edit in my head a keep it there. It’s better because you can do things that aren’t possible. But it’s harder to upload to Google Drive.

Well, even cheap storage isn’t anything for me to laugh at these days.

I’m betting on the day after I eventually delete my master ProRes file, meaning I’d have to potentially do a lot more work to get back up and running.

Indeed. I don’t have much time or headspace to delve into this one, and probably wouldn’t really spark much, so I’m dedicated to putting out my regular TROS edit and then plugging in whatever consensus or best approach emerges from this discussion.

There are BD25 (mkv) versions also, but I do not have storage space on Google Drive to use to host them. For now they’re available via torrents you can search for. 😕

I feel ya. Part of me wants to avoid getting sucked into Hobbit fan editing beyond just paring down the Maple Films edit, so I’m reluctant to have to get to know something else unless it wows me in a preliminary way.
BUT, I will check it out further whenever I have spare time. Probably won’t sit through the whole thing, though; I had a hard enough time carving out time to watch Bill and Ted 3!

I didn’t realize that it was your work. Well, I don’t mean to say that it’s without any merit just because I have a shorthand way to quickly inspect one thing, nor that my litmus test is conclusive. I just speak from a place of comfort with an edit I’d seen a few times before and has a few unique things about it that sell it for me over others.

I don’t mean to sound dismissive, just that I am not able to thoroughly check out a Hobbit edit I come across at this point. Like I said, though, it’s the Second best version of that sequence that I have seen, and pulls off such a transition best that I’ve come across. i’m sure it would be worthwhile to check the edit out more thoroughly and meant no insult.

I agree completely. More time may not have helped, but I still think they should have allowed for it. Even that may have allowed them to find someone other than JJ Abrams.

It’s Disney’s fault for having such a tight deadline. When Carrie passed, they should have pushed it back a year. No one external forced the release date.

Abrams was given a daunting task. I still don’t like what he pulled off, but fault depends on how you frame it.

Hit me up.

Thank you, I appreciate the feedback. I like this one a lot, too.

Well it’s not a showstopper if it can’t be done, so we’ll just see what shakes out for it. Fortunately it won’t affect overall sync, for other things that could be done first.

Ben says, “…And no questions asked.”

Han asks, “What is it, some kind of local trouble?”

Ben repeats, “No questions asked.”

Okay I take back what I just said. At present, a good Poe line and a few more miscellaneous whoops and hollers, not to mention removing the watermark, and we’ll be golden.

😄

mrbenjamino said:

Cinefy said:

Hal 9000 said:

Okay, so here’s this. We can certainly give Poe a line or two from video games or whatever, and add a few more hollers from people sending in audio.

Y’know, things like “let’s give 'em hell!” and “ASS!”

https://vimeo.com/457355065

I still think that kid shouting “we believe in you Poe” is too loud, lol.

ouch lmao

Lol, I’m glad you said it. I like the line.

Those lines were edited nicely for how the original scene is.
I wonder if it might be bette to cut to Wedge at the same point we originally would cut to Poe, then cut back and hear “For Skywalker,” along with some other cries as the shot carries on longer.

Eh, probably not. It’s better to let the shot continue unbroken and then see Wedge before cutting to a different exterior shot.

Anyone know any good Poe lines to fit this situation?

Ziggy’s idea works well. I muted the trooper’s line about identifying them and shortened that shot by about half.

“Hold it right there!”

Points blaster at them, adjusting aim to cover them

“All units—-“ DEAD

I didn’t use a wipe or iris to transition; the shots are so short and it’s not a time jump.

Without editing it at all, overlay this audio over every air combat scene in the ST:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFTmi9esb6c

PM sent.

I just want to ignore Ashsoka’s existence and the resurrection of Maul, because both feel incongruous with the films. But the Filoni-verse keeps over spilling. I don’t want to see Maul in the Kenobi show for crap’s sake!

Me, too, please.

PM sent.

Noted. I want to mail down the ‘blocking’ of the little sequence before I get into the grittier audio aspects. Does it feel right to have the extended shot play over what used to be a cutaway to Poe, then play out the equivalent duration longer?

Axlanian did a great job mixing the cries and yells to the old blocking of shots, so I’m wondering if it feels right to have a couple whoops, Poe can say something vague about “wow let’s go” and then a couple “For Skywalker”s at the same point in the music as before, followed by a bit more enthused chatter.