Doctor M

User Group: Members
Join date: 1-Feb-2005
Last activity: 25-Apr-2024
Posts: 2,530

Post History

Post: #91461
Topic: MagnoliaFan Edits: Ep I "Balance Of The Force", and Ep II "The Clone War" (Released)
Link: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/91461/action/topic#91461
Time: 2-Feb-2005 1:16 PM

MJR80: Check out MySpleen.net. You'll need to sign up for an account, and install a bittorrent client.

Everyone else: Ok, I'd love to see the alternate titles if anyone wants to PM me.

Post: #91466
Topic: Who has caved?
Link: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/91466/action/topic#91466
Time: 2-Feb-2005 7:23 AM

Haven't seen them, won't buy them. Maybe borrow from the local library so I can yell at my TV.

TOP 3 Reasons:

Lucas is actually considering episodes 7, 8, 9. That means more changes to come to the OT. Maybe removing the Corisant celebration?

2007=30th Anniversary: Bluray (HDDVD?) big momma jomma set is in the works. Can you say all 6 movies reworked, again... Maybe we can hope for original versions on these, but my breathe isn't held.

I LOVE the original versions. I saw the SE's in the theater (yes all 3), and almost cried.

Post: #91360
Topic: Star Wars - The Edits and DVDr releases thread
Link: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/91360/action/topic#91360
Time: 2-Feb-2005 12:36 AM

Oh, one more thing, are there 'official' covers/dvd labels that match the Farsight set?

[Edit]
Nevermind, just found them on disc 4.

I see 3 files in .DVD format. Assumingly the disc labels.
Anyone know what program can read that?

Post: #91355
Topic: Star Wars - The Edits and DVDr releases thread
Link: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/91355/action/topic#91355
Time: 1-Feb-2005 11:39 PM

I hope you'll all excuse the n00b question, but after much lurking, reading and LOTS of d/l'ding, I have found myself more pleased with the visual quality of the Farsight transfer (which I know makes me a bit of an oddity).

As I recall the only true defect is the missing Leai welding scene.

Can anyone give me specifics as to WHAT that scene is, about how long, and maybe a time-frame in the movie?
I'd like to see it for myself to decide how important it is to me (I have the TR47 version as well, just don't want to sit through the whole film to find the scene not knowing what I'm looking for.)

Finally I got to say I'm so in love with what I've seen on project Zion, I cannot wait.

And also, a huge thank you to the community. I had vaguely considered doing a DVD transfer myself with my hugely inadequate knowledge, a PC with a line in and a LD player. I can't imagine the time and effort that all of you have put into these.

Post: #91231
Topic: MagnoliaFan Edits: Ep I "Balance Of The Force", and Ep II "The Clone War" (Released)
Link: https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/91231/action/topic#91231
Time: 1-Feb-2005 4:31 PM

Just watched BotF, and am willing to give CW as chance.

Just a couple of quick comments (not that everyone else hasn't given their $.02.

Xvid encoding: Large size file yet still looks poor with tinny audio (and occasional audio echos). How come? The file is large enough to be pretty damn amazing from an edited DVD source. Also the aspect ration is a bit wonkey in some players. I use something fairly standard (Media Player Classic), yet I have to switch to WMP to get the aspect ration correct when watching. I don't have this problem with other Xvids.

Movie itself: Great. Loved that you moved some plot points to the front and changed some of the relationships. Muzzling JarJar and whiney Anakin makes the movie tolerable again. I'd love more character development now, but if Lucas didn't shoot it, there's not much that can be done there.

My only complaint is about the subtitled languages. I can live with the scrambled audio. Any collection of sounds have the possibility of being a language somewhere. I also have to believe that there are some sort of universal translators, that people DO understand multiple languages, or that JarJar is a jackass and makes comments to people who don't understand a word he's saying. (Heck I didn't understand Boss Nass when he spoken ENGLISH).

BUT, that being said, the subtitles could be better timed (and are long winded for the period given to read them). It might work better if they were a larger type-face. I watch on a 19" TV and by the time I make out the titles I usually miss the end of them.

Finally, some of the added titled dialog needs revision. The idea is good, but actor responses are quite often inappropriate to the new context.
Example: Kill them/his family - Actor's physical body language: Ok let's go.
I don't have to kill you human's after all - (And there was much rejoicing)(?)
Etc.
Also, some dialog sounds clunky in the context of the SW universe. And what's this about a stolen Gungan crystal? It's just now how the OT would have sounded if Lucas made these 15 years ago.

I guess what I'm saying is you need a re-write, but the ides are quite good.
Should we expect a version 2?