STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW — Page 445

Darth Piccolo said:

vaderios said:

I love most ROTS sabers for the reasons that ady hates them. I read millions od topics about how the sabers should looks etc etc. I dont care if he will make them with more gradient glow! I know the fact that what he is going to do will be awesome!

 

-Angel

 

i don't know from what i can tell it seems he wants to change it just for the sake of it or just for the sake of nitpicking.  i mean really does changing the sabers really further the story?

heck i'm all for him tweaking the pt stories to match the ot, i'm glad he is going to replace the bad cg sets (aotc) with real sets and dumbing down the unnessary effects to match the ot. i'm all for that.

 

Why is is that when someone doesn't agree with something i'm doing sometimes they sue the "changing it for the sake of it.." line. I have stated from the very beginning of these edits that the PT will be changed to fit the OT. I also stated from the beginning that i will be changing the lightsabers in the PT to match the OT versions. That includes lightsabers. They don't look the same in the PT and even the blue colouring is different and so is the pointy tip. To create some form of continuity they HAVE to be changed to match the OT ones. i made a mock-up (very rough ones)of the Revisited PT sabers.

I know which ones i prefer. :)

As for the "stardestroyer" line, it's not something that has ever bothered me and still doesn't so i can't see myself doing anything to that. Maybe she isn't actually Anakin's child but is in fact Ric Olie's. lol

Okay...you asked for it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qF76lk9yiyo

i think the line sounds like a video game...or ric narrator ollie 

adywan said:

i made a mock-up (very quick one)of the Revisited PT sabers.

Now that's a preview for something a LONG way away!  LOL

Davnes007 said:

Okay...you asked for it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qF76lk9yiyo

My post got lost in the crowd...lol

The ROTS sabers looked like they were made in microsoft paint. I mean look at the OT sabers they were moving and hissing they looked like they could cut something. The ROTS sabers looked like glowing night sticks that would piss off an enemy more than kill them

sans_fi said:

First the probe aproaching, then Luke sees the probe crashing with his music and his dialogue, then the wampa arrives and knocks Luke, and then the probe Droid appears out of the crater...  I dont know, it still doesnt feel right, too many things happens between the droid crashing and the droid coming out.

Now that's sounding like the end of any of the prequels, especially TPM. :)

The sequence of events is fine as is.  At no time in the past or present did I have any trouble with the sequence.  Both "hits" are necessary to the film: The probe lands on Hoth after we see them being launched, then Luke sees it land and gives him the motivation to go check it out.  The probes are being launched throughout the system and although Hoth is probably a huge place, I don't see why the Empire would send two to the same planet when they are making a blanket search.

For those interested, full-res copies of my ANH:R (version 2) and new ESB:R covers are in my sig.

Nice sabers, Ady. I dunno if I like the blue or green one better.

This is going to sound goofy, but I know someone has tried yellow sabers before, but what about orange?

Another thing with the way the clip ends - It sort of has the possibility of Luke knowing the probe is there, telling Han about it. Then he wants to go check it out, but gets rudely interupted by the Wampa, etc.

adywan said:

 Maybe she isn't actually Anakin's child but is in fact Ric Olie's. lol

 

Hahaha....Very good adyman!!

And I vote blue for Windu...Only cos it rhymes!!

Damn! Cyan sabers in PT. Sounds out of place! or maybe not..

Either way same sabers in the entire trilogy from its own a big goal.

-Angel

Ripplin said:

Nice sabers, Ady. I dunno if I like the blue or green one better.

This is going to sound goofy, but I know someone has tried yellow sabers before, but what about orange?

Why choose?  How about "barberpole"?  Or maybe striped, like AIM toothpaste?  :-)p

maybe hue cycling?

one color for each frame?

Davnes007 said:

Okay...you asked for it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qF76lk9yiyo

 

 

I suppose that works out okay until the probe droid pops his head out (that messes with continuity and Luke's line about a "meteor"), although when watching the probe coming closer to the planet I felt like yelling out "Holy shit!  Luke watch out!  That thing's gonna land on your head!  Look up, damnit!  Look up!!!" :)

Davnes007 said:

Another thing with the way the clip ends - It sort of has the possibility of Luke knowing the probe is there, telling Han about it. Then he wants to go check it out, but gets rudely interupted by the Wampa, etc.

I like it, and think it would work even better if you inserted the probe droid leaving after he gets dragged away by the Wampa.  Not sure if its necessary, but someone can use it!

Since we've digressed into prequel saber matching, I would suggest changing all the Jedi sabers to blue for the entirety of the prequels.  It makes Luke's green saber all the more distinguishing and could imply his lack of knowledge on lightsaber making in general, and the green hue is a result of his experimentation.  Sure, more colors are awfully pretty, but not necessary.

As a completely non-OT:R subject but related to Ady's mock-up, I would also suggest making Mace the only Jedi to confront Palpy.  This may be a nightmare to edit (both visually and auditory), but if pulled off would add a lot to Mason J. Windu's character.  Just something to file away until 2019....

Savage said:

As a completely non-OT:R subject but related to Ady's mock-up, I would also suggest making Mace the only Jedi to confront Palpy.  This may be a nightmare to edit (both visually and auditory), but if pulled off would add a lot to Mason J. Windu's character.  Just something to file away until 2019....

i will be doing that.

adywan said:

Savage said:

As a completely non-OT:R subject but related to Ady's mock-up, I would also suggest making Mace the only Jedi to confront Palpy.  This may be a nightmare to edit (both visually and auditory), but if pulled off would add a lot to Mason J. Windu's character.  Just something to file away until 2019....

i will be doing that.

Cool, saves all of those Jedi from dying in the dumbest way imaginable.

Weird that we're actually getting more information about Ep3R (I'm doubting the original names will be kept) than ESBR today... ;-)

adywan said:

Savage said:

As a completely non-OT:R subject but related to Ady's mock-up, I would also suggest making Mace the only Jedi to confront Palpy.  This may be a nightmare to edit (both visually and auditory), but if pulled off would add a lot to Mason J. Windu's character.  Just something to file away until 2019....

i will be doing that.

 

wow so no apperance in that scene for Kit Fisto and the others? Interesting. 

sans_fi said:

This is some kind of personal thing, and it will affect the story IN A HUGE WAY... It mainly affects ROTJ, but there is one little scene here.

Dont make Luke and Leia Brother and Sister... It just feels forced and stupid. It makes no sense that nobody ever felt the force in her, why obi-wan never even cared about her rescue on A New Hope, why nor yoda nor obi-wan even cared training her AT THE SAME TIME as Luke. And it breaks that tension between Han-Leia-Luke, without really giving anything to the story.

It wouldnt be that hard to edit from ROTJ, the biggest change would be how to make luke get angry with vader... But any other time is just cutting dialogue.

In ESB youll have to cut down the "No, there is another" (thats why im posting this here first and not waiting untill ROTJ:R)

People are already talking about it on the Wishlist.