yoshif8tures

Glad you’re doing okay. Slightly miffed that you deleted all your good stuff though 😅

revel911 said:

yoshif8tures said:

DarthWolvo said:

It would be nice if the Naboo flashback could stay as we rarely get to see Naboo in the era of the Empire

I’d say that scene slows the pace down

I like it as it it shows the rebellion taking the fight straight to Palpatine’s home planet.

Yes, but I’d argue that for the purposes of this edit, it’s completely unnecessary

DarthWolvo said:

It would be nice if the Naboo flashback could stay as we rarely get to see Naboo in the era of the Empire

I’d say that scene slows the pace down

For a movie cut, I think a lot of her scenes can be cut or trimmed out now. Her struggles with drugs and her nightmares don’t really lead anywhere that pushes the main storyline, and yes her and Cassian bombing the doctor has no connection it and isn’t mentioned at all.

An someone send me a link to this plz

MY I have a link plz

May I have a link
Please

can’t wait!

Sounds good. I watched your initial cut and it’s an improvement so far.

Patali said:

Farm planet, boring, it’s gone.

Yavin 4, insufferable characters that are never once made relatable. It’s gone.

Mon Mothma plot, heavily, heavily trimmed.

Syril and Dedra… pretty good plot actually. Did not take up too much run time, scenes were punchy.

Agreed. Farm planet was a drag and didn’t really add much, most of it can be cut. Mon rave scene can be trimmed as well as endless chitchat about marriage problems which is irrelevant.
Yavin rebels were insufferable and I was hoping Cassian would put them out of their misery as he took flight.
i would also cut the pep talk he had with the imperial tech before he stole the fighter since it didn’t really add anything important. Also cut the imps showing a retro video since it was too on the nose n@zi. Yes we know the imps are space versions, but flat out copying them is just too earthy for me.

I would trim the farm scenes as well as the opeing with the imperial engineer.

timdiggerm said:

yoshif8tures said:

oojason said:

 

The same critics also said TLJ was the best Star Wars movie ever too…

I can not find a review online of The Last Jedi by Nicholas Quah. Do you have a source you can cite?

Let me clarify. Movie critics in general said TLJ was the best Star Wars movie ever, which it was not.
Now the same people say andor is the best.
My point being that their word has absolutely no weight at all.

oojason said:

 

The same critics also said TLJ was the best Star Wars movie ever too…

I’d love to see it!

Hype!
Honestly this is the most exciting Star Wars project for years!

I’ve caught up again and can’t wait to see what you’ve cooked up

May I have a link please

I was checking the cut list and got really confused as they seem completely different to what I’m watching. Is it out of date now?

I just finished watching this, and it was really solid. I’d probably watch it again and might even check out the original episodes now. To me, it looked like it had a higher budget than any Disney+ show—the space battles and planets were far more interesting.

My only critique is that it sort of comes to a sudden end and feels a bit open-ended. That might be an issue with the original source material, though.

Overall, I really liked it and would recommend it!

looking forward to this!

JoyOfEditing said:

yoshif8tures said:

Looks good. Have you done whole film?

. . . I’ve actually recut all six of George’s films lol!

Let’s see them!

Looks good. Have you done whole film?

Why’s it called skeleton crew anyway?
As someone who only watched the first 2 episodes and has already forgotten it, I’d like to see this when it’s ready, love all your edits smudger 😊

Hopefully

This was a well crafted fast paced story. There were a few moments that I missed seeing in the show, but he does as intended and gives us a great movie cut.
Well worth watching!