Keyan Farlander said:
Caston said:
Many of the comments in the Star Wars Underworld twitter thread makes some very good points, and the majority are wanting the theatrical cuts being released, or are calling George out for him comments.
That is pleasing to see, that most see straight through George and his claims.
Yeah, it appears the days of George just repeating shit until it becomes an accepted “truth” by many fans are long gone (other than the lazy/clickbait media and George/Prequel worshippers, of course!)
The following abridged screenshot (edited for length) is from Lucasfilm department director Bill Kimberlin’s excellent 2018 book - Inside The Star Wars Empire, from ‘The Distraction’ chapter, starting on Page 194.
It covers George Lucas refusing the option to have a duplicate negative of the original cuts to be made. Something that “could be easily done”. Instead George simply said “This is the original version” (meaning the 1997 SE cut was now “the original version”):
So when George used to tell everyone all the many excuses in the past as to why he couldn’t preserve or restore the original cuts, it was all rubbish. For someone who even today goes on record about the importance of preserving film history, George actively suppressed the preservation and archiving of his own film, as well as the films of other directors in the Original Trilogy.
Lucas is also on record as specifically wanting the original cuts of the OT films to no longer exist:
George Lucas: “There will only be one. And it won’t be what I would call the ‘rough cut’, it’ll be the 'final cut.’”
^ a screenshot from “How the Grinch Stole Star Wars” - an article from the Save Star Wars website.
(from Category No. 17 of the ‘George Lucas: Star Wars Creator, Unreliable Narrator & Time Travelling Revisionist…’ thread)
The entire “Inside The Star Wars Empire” book is a really good enjoyable read and would recommend anyone to go and buy it.