s88

I appreciate the insights offered (even you Grand Admiral). I do acknowledge there is no ‘one way’ and the points made regarding the original material making it difficult to find an alternative storyline is completely justified.

My repetitive take is there is no balance to the fan edit offerings for tRoS. The majority have felt the need to include the third act arc (knowing the transparent desperation of Disney exec’s) so in essence the talented community has decided to keep resurrecting the wrongs already committed. I hope for more diversity to the tROS fan edits to bring balance to the…

amobex said:

s88 said:

We all know the original release was poorly executed but I can’t believe there is not a consensus that Palpatine’s return was epically bad writing and a desperate attempt to make episode 9 relevant. Why are you not investing the time and expertise to cutting out Palpatine altogether. There is only one fan edit which has done this and whilst flawed, it still made a very good attempt.

You are all supporting the Star Wars 9 episodes essentially being the ‘Story of Sheev’.

What a joke.

Cool. Where can we watch your edit that gives us a movie that was never made?

I can only recommend this one.
https://originaltrilogy.com/topic/A-Palpatine-less-Edit-of-The-Rise-of-Skywalker-Released/id/74454
There are far too many of you wasting your time and expertise on resurrecting a dead Sith because you lack the will to simply omit him from episode 9. The judgement on this is as poor as the original tRoS movie was.

We all know the original release was poorly executed but I can’t believe there is not a consensus that Palpatine’s return was epically bad writing and a desperate attempt to make episode 9 relevant. Why are you not investing the time and expertise to cutting out Palpatine altogether. There is only one fan edit which has done this and whilst flawed, it still made a very good attempt.

You are all supporting the Star Wars 9 episodes essentially being the ‘Story of Sheev’.

What a joke.

Would appreciate a link please, thanks for all your effort.