Can’t wait to watch this, going through everything to prepare for Doomsday with my kids and was looking for a “movie” version to cut watch time down and get a more cohesive story!
Did you find this? I never got a response.
Love this.
Only thing else I would love is a slightly more more modern but digital soundtrack.
Very interested!
I just wish we had a brotherhood quality version so we can just replace the episodes of Tucker.
Tell me more about how the villains feels consistent or work together?
Excited to see it and one day, hoping to trim a version into Adywan’s ANH.
I am very interested because the wedding was always a distraction.
Oh, I am so in for this. Adding a bit of Queen to also help put you in the Highlander mood?
@Booshman
Thanks for the critiques! I’m glad you enjoyed it. I’ll try to answer your thoughts below:I made the choice to split some episodes from beyond the wall and the battle at winterfell because I felt it gave an illusion of longer time for one thing, and also it helped a bit with some of the fast travel. I agree that the 30 minute episodes were too short, but after playing around with them I felt like this was the best choice for what I had.
I tried really hard to make each scene change have different people for a natural flow, but there were a few times where it just wasn’t working.
The biggest change I’d like to make if I ever go back to this would be to fix the Bran VO. Some people were okay with the volume, and others obviously weren’t. Audio editing is the most challenging part to me, but hopefully I can fix it up.
Glad the visual effects worked! Only thing was at the end I wanted more dead in the funeral, but I could only manage a few characters because of the footage.
Dialogue for Jon is difficult. I actually went through two voice over actors. One didn’t work out and I just wasted time and money, but the one I had was a guy from youtube who was one of the better ones out there. I think if it was a normal scene with Jon talking like he usually does it would have fit better, but because it was a quieter scene he didn’t know how to impersonate it as well.
Can you use AI to put Kit’s voice over your VO’s?
How long is each of the movies?
It would be nice if the Naboo flashback could stay as we rarely get to see Naboo in the era of the Empire
I’d say that scene slows the pace down
I like it as it it shows the rebellion taking the fight straight to Palpatine’s home planet.
Using the Star Wars Crawl? If so, thoughts about doing it in red?
I much prefer the idea of 3, 2 hour movie blocks as I like my movie closer to the 2 hour form than the 3. LOTR was supposed to be the oddity, not the norm.
Can I get link?
What percentage is this completed?
So excited for this release.
I love Ady’s edits as they are what I personally consider ideal Star Wars, but I will donate once ANH is out, till then it feels wrong to me to ask for something for project Y, when project X hasn’t been completed.
- And again, as has been brought up multiple times now, why does Jod tell the pirates to attack? Wouldn’t a better tactic have been to simply replace the Supervisor and send shipments of credits out to his crew every few months? Could you somehow imply that this was his original plan but that it had been blocked by something, maybe the kids blowing the cover on him or his ship’s actual identity? That way, just like with the kids, he would start out trying to be a friend, but if needed, he would change angles and use fear to get what he wants.
Attacking was so stupid. A “we are moving credits to the rebuilding of the new republic after the Empire fell” and “now that the false Empire is gone, Jedi are now again running the galaxy” were easy lies.
Some good ideas here-
Star Wars: Inside the Death Star During Its Destruction-
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lF5cOg8-ZFQMmm… I don’t think so.
Some of it is WAY overdone, but there are a few shots there of the deathstar melting from different angles that look great.
No shade your way, but probably because there are already so many fan edits of Kenobi, plus everyone is anticipating pixeljoker95’s edit.
And if that ever comes out, so we may as well keep going.
I would love to see the robots given an alien language (they are robots for the Neimoidians, right?)
preview coming soon:
Anyway to make the screen a bit more hi-res?
Out of curiosity, would you consider adding in the blue energy shields, similar to what was shown in Revenge Of The Sith, to the Death Star?
Here is a quick mock-up of what I mean:
I don’t think so. That’s too drastic of a change to add for something that only appears in one non-original trilogy film.
Stinks as I like the idea. This is a bit too dramatic, but does give the feeling of separating everyone from space.
