Sign In

rainbow battle kid

User Group
Trusted Members
Join date
21-May-2015
Last activity
6-Dec-2018
Posts
40

Post History

Post
#1252420
Topic
4K versions vs. DEED
Time

So my question is, colorwise, is 4k83’s colors kinda “off” because of what they need to do for theaters, or are the DEED (and blu-ray) colors kinda like, artificially sweetened to look more like modern movies? I also suspect I’ll prefer the despecialized in the long run, and probably prefer it to 4K83 based on my initial look, but 4k77 DNR looks amazing

Post
#1252411
Topic
4K83 Released
Time

Yeah I get that they’re different projects, I just wasn’t sure which way is more like, Authentic or whatever, though again I guess that’s different too. I guess maybe my question is, is the film’s color slightly “off” or is the blu-ray etc sort of artificially sweetened?

And yeah I thought it looked a little brighter during the bright scenes, like a lot of the Jabba stuff, just darker in some others. Maybe my laptop is weird but the Luke/Ben scene is WAY darker and bluer than the Desp.

Post
#1252393
Topic
4K83 Released
Time

So I got this yesterday and compared it to Despecialized and some of the darker scenes (luke & ghost ben, throne room) look way darker and bluer and like, to my untrained eyes, not quite as good, but are those colors more accurate? the ben scenes look appropriately moodier but the throne room just looks darker in a way that looks off when I go to it from the Desp. Also used the Luke/Yoda scene to test and felt like it was also kinda similar. Would love any insights

Post
#1215119
Topic
4k77 released
Time

for the record i can’t stand the special editions lol

i just like the other non-prequel films and it bugs me if SW77 is the only one without the episode number, plus that original crawl DOES look off to me because it’s not what my vhs had.

i certainly understand preferring the original though, and the value of historically preserving it. it just sucks cause i feel like people either fall into “don’t care about the changes”, or “only want the original theatrical 77 version” and it’s tough being not QUITE in one camp or the other when the ONLY change I like is the 81 crawl

Post
#1214774
Topic
4k77 released
Time

boy that escalated quickly, lol

yeah if anyone ends up making the 81 version, let me know or make a new thread or something!

i know it’s not the ORIGINAL, but that’s the version i grew up with on VHS, plus it’s a small change that makes it match the other 2 movies so I really don’t mind it as a change. but certainly i know that’s not the point of most of these restorations, it would just be nice to have the option if someone with the skills and inclination makes it 😃

and yeah i’m definitely rockin that ANH 2.7 😃

that’s actually the main thing keeping me from switching to the SSE or this

Post
#905954
Topic
Harmy's RETURN OF THE JEDI Despecialized Edition HD (AVCHD DVD9 & NTSC DVD5 available!!! SEE FIRST POST!!!)
Time

man i was listening to it with the BD commentary track while cleaning the house, and i got to vader picking up the emperor and him yelling “NOO!!” and i was like “WAIT WHAT???” and it took me a second to realize obviously i’m just hearing the background audio from the blu ray. threw me off for a second like “how did he miss that??”