Sign In

oviniboy

User Group
Members
Join date
19-Jul-2019
Last activity
6-Aug-2022
Posts
150

Post History

Post
#1447791
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

I think the scene works better with the saber sound, but IMO this pass it’s a bit too loud and, i don’t know how to put this, still sounds a bit like just an added foley over the scene and not a diegetic sound, maybe by muffling it a bit helps to make it all come together. The work itself is fenomenal as always, just not quite there yet for me.

Post
#1447618
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

oojason said:

TestingOutTheTest said:

Head mod unbanned me with another chance. I spent a lot of time on /r/saltierthancrait (former hater here!) and /r/saltierthankrayt.

Just to quickly address this. I’m not a head mod - or anything like.

Though you were indeed given yet another chance - which you blew right through and continued on as before your temp-ban. As you know, the temp-ban was to give you some time away to re-think your posting style and attitude to fan editors / creators on here. It is a shame you chose to ignore the advice and efforts of members on here who went out of their way to help you and carried on regardless upon your return. Not to mention lying to the site staff.
 

My apologies to Hal for going off-topic.

Let’s get back to the subject of this sweet TROS Edit. 👍
 

good wins after all

Post
#1444767
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

Neerb said:
According to the front page:

  • Leia sensing the end of her Jedi path. Sherlockpotter was working on it earlier this week and it seems to be going along well. The v4 is sounding really great.

  • Luke’s haircut. Jonh has been gone since May, probably busy with real life, but last we heard he was still working on it.

Thanks, Neerb!

I think Sherlock’s work is superb in this part, i really can’t see how it can be improved.
About the haircut, as Jonh is prob super busy, won’t be better if we just proceed with the scene without the haircut for now and leave to a future V2.1 or something?

Also, anyone has news on MR? Been a while since he last showed up.

Post
#1439168
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

Personally, at this point, the whole mess about how Palps returned is part of the fun to me.
Is he a clone? Is he a ghost? Is that his original body? How he’s still alive? Is he just a walking corpse? Is he now a space lich or something? Is he a metaphor for how the movie industry just insists in the same ideas over and over for decades until they rot away and become only a shadow of their former selves? Who knows?? Who cares???
I know it’s still messy, and perhaps I just got used to it, but well, it’s a movie about space samurai wizards, so I think as far as this edit can go, Palpatine’s returnal it’s enough for me, more would break the fun, it doesn’t answer clearly but it doesn’t leave us in the dark like the theatrical cut (thanks Poppa)

Post
#1437942
Topic
The Rise of Skywalker: Ascendant (Released)
Time

What are we exactly looking for? It is a “I am a” or just a “a” to frankenstein it on the scene? Because if the latter work, if it matches the tone and feel, i don’t think it would be a big problem if it is Daisy or not. And again, only us, crazy nerds, would know that (and probably only notice because we know it).
Perhaps we can test it and see how it goes.