ohnochuck

I’ve sampled all the fan edits I can get my hands on and yours are the best both in terms of judgement of what to leave in and take out and skill/techinical quality of the edits, so take this with that in mind–you seem open to feedback, unlike some fan editors…

I’ve showed your edits to a couple groups of people (they were generally very well-recieved) in preparation for TFA and everyone is a little baffled by the Padme’s family scene. I get that you used it to make up for some of the romance stuff you cut out but it just raises a lot more questions than it answers re: the political system and royalty of Naboo. Plus it’s as embarrassingly bad of a scene as any of the Anakin/Padme scenes you cut. Hope you don’t use it in the eagerly-anticipated-'round-these-parts V4.

Anyway, thanks for the best versions of the prequels out there, I cringe whenever terribly-edited versions make the blog headline rounds just because they’re on Youtube.