Master Lawdog

Centurion said:

Sounds like a wonderful project!

Thank you!

rquinlan1001 said:

Ok now how many chapters left? 7? 8? 9?

Currently nine. If I have enough time, I could potentially finish Order of the Phoenix by this upcoming weekend.

rquinlan1001 said:

Master Lawdog said:

Darth Muffy said:

Hi Noah, good to see your getting the recognition you deserve from Potter fans for this project and your conviction to finishing it as too many people lose their enjoyment along the way within their projects and never get round to seeing it through.

Nice work so far though and look forward to hearing the next enhanced audiobook whenever you feel its ready. 👍

Thanks, Muffy. I have seen many people lose interest on big long projects, with the exception of perhaps Adywan. However, that doesn’t mean I am going to leave this incomplete. I will say that I will not be doing any other audiobooks around Harry Potter such as Fantastic Beasts or the Cursed Child.

Good. I’m glad you and I are fans who love to pretend stuff that came after deathly hallows never existed. The Movieflame guy is like that too

Yeah. I am familiar with Morgan Ross of Movieflame. This and my Sonic X project are my biggest projects yet.

I do want to see how the remaining three Fantastic Beasts films turn out, even though I wasn’t too enthusiastic with how Crimes of Grindelwald turned out. I also am not sure exactly what the HBO Max series will be like and whether J.K. Rowling will have any say into its creation.

Darth Muffy said:

Hi Noah, good to see your getting the recognition you deserve from Potter fans for this project and your conviction to finishing it as too many people lose their enjoyment along the way within their projects and never get round to seeing it through.

Nice work so far though and look forward to hearing the next enhanced audiobook whenever you feel its ready. 👍

Thanks, Muffy. I have seen many people lose interest on big long projects, with the exception of perhaps Adywan. However, that doesn’t mean I am going to leave this incomplete. I will say that I will not be doing any other audiobooks around Harry Potter such as Fantastic Beasts or the Cursed Child.

poppasketti said:

Master Lawdog said:

Any chance a V4 could happen, or is this project fully complete?

Hey Lawdog,

I don’t have any changes in mind right now. I’ve already made the updates based around TROS, so I consider this project basically finished. It’s also an especially busy time in my life, and I don’t expect to have time to make any major updates. I wouldn’t say never though!

Okay, I understand. Thanks, poppasketti.

bbghost said:

Master Lawdog said:

Here is a compilation of scenes for how Rey Nobody can work. Let me know what you all think.

https://vimeo.com/580074316
PASSWORD: fanedit

“The only family you have here is me.”

Not sure how that line works in this context?

It could work as in Rey only having Palpatine to be with. He could’ve said something like that to Vader after losing Padmé.

Peonthegrate said:

In cannon there isn’t yet an explanation as to how Anakin turned into a force ghost, atleast I think.
I believe before EU became legends, here was some novelization that said Obi-Wan told Vader how to do it right before Vader had died. In his head similar to how Obi-Wan contacted Luke.

I mainly remember that in the epilogue to the 2007 novelization, The Rise and Fall of Darth Vader by Ryder Windham.

Peonthegrate said:

Its lore breaking because Qui gon cannot become a force ghost, he was only able to become a voice, never able to fully become visible as stated in the clone wars.

Mace was never taught the ability either. And Ahsoka has never been shown to have died yet, the reason you can hear her voice is because the novelization shows rey was sort of looking into the world between worlds if that makes sense, so it would likely not age well.

I suppose you are right, but if I remember, didn’t Obi-Wan and Yoda help Anakin appear physically in the afterlife so he could see Luke and Leia on Endor? It’s possible that they could’ve helped the others as well. Just a thought, that’s all.

I know what Hal wants, I’m just hoping jonh will export V3 for Hal to add to the Drive folder as an alternative for other editors to use.

Plus, even though we don’t know how Ahsoka died yet, she clearly is dead since you hear her voice, along with Mace Windu give Rey advice. And I don’t think anyone is going to go by the fan theory that Windu survived his fall.

Peonthegrate said:

I sure hope we don’t have mace and ahsoka etc… it breaks the lore.

How so?

omnimuffin said:

Master Lawdog said:

CamSMurph said:

Will the epic force ghost ending be updated in any way based on jon_h’s recent progress? 😃

I do hope he gets back and exports the V3 that adds Leia, Qui-Gon, Mace Windu and Ahsoka.

Also, I don’t know how possible it is to have Anakin be portrayed by Sebastian Shaw instead of Hayden Christensen.

Is this viewable anywhere? It sounds really cool.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iT0HAvqB-EA

CamSMurph said:

Will the epic force ghost ending be updated in any way based on jon_h’s recent progress? 😃

I do hope he gets back and exports the V3 that adds Leia, Qui-Gon, Mace Windu and Ahsoka.

Also, I don’t know how possible it is to have Anakin be portrayed by Sebastian Shaw instead of Hayden Christensen.

Any word back from jonh?

Any progress made lately on these projects, JJ?

How is the progression of ideas going on here now?

Eleven chapters left to go on Order of the Phoenix!

Is it possible in the shot where Kylo Ren’s saber is glowing before he turns it on to kill Lor San Tekka to digitally remove the glow than cropping it out? Just curious.

Any chance a V4 could happen, or is this project fully complete?

I never understood exactly why Hal wants, “I’m all the Jedi” to be replaced with, “I am a Jedi.”

Or to The Rise of Skywalker.

parris1000 said:

These are seriously amazing. I had already listened to the standard Stephen Fry PS and COS audiobooks and enjoyed them, but your enhanced editions take these to a whole new level. I can’t thank you enough for sharing these. Just wonderful.

Thank you very much!

sherlockpotter said:

Had some time to fiddle with “Leia sensed the end” some more. Still needs some clean up, but…is this at least in the right direction?

https://streamable.com/mghfm0

I’m starting to think that this might be the right way to go, since the focus of the scene is Luke passing Leia’s Jedi legacy onto Rey, and less on Ben.

hiphats said:

Master Lawdog said:

hiphats said:

I have seen this so-called edit on archive.org . Beware ! This is not the Selutron edit and does not contain the revised changes you saw on Oliver Harper’s vlog. This is apparently the work of one other fan who had too much time on his/her hands. This is one fan’s way of combining the theatrical cut with the Donner version. Wait a bit longer, folks, before attempting another version of S2.

Huh? What about the VFX changes that Selutron did? Were they just select scene tests to pitch a conceptualized idea, or are they scenes from his project?

They were scenes from his project.

So still hasn’t been found then? And his project was based on the original script by Tom Mankiewicz?

hiphats said:

I have seen this so-called edit on archive.org . Beware ! This is not the Selutron edit and does not contain the revised changes you saw on Oliver Harper’s vlog. This is apparently the work of one other fan who had too much time on his/her hands. This is one fan’s way of combining the theatrical cut with the Donner version. Wait a bit longer, folks, before attempting another version of S2.

Huh? What about the VFX changes that Selutron did? Were they just select scene tests to pitch a conceptualized idea, or are they scenes from his project?