neohanime

yufuhe, Mr Rabbit, Xylobryte7, vorpalnonsense, nomadlamb

PM’d.

false said:

Hey, @neohanime, it looks like I was 5 hours too late to the party but I would love a link for all three too please. Much thanks!

PM’d.

aj99, ajthenoob, alenqe, amaguma_kun, arafaba, arcanium, argot, aristofeles, Armoreds22, ArsInvictus, Arvyss, Ashkan420, ashlain96, astror, astrotits, Audicted, AVicario10, azeemx, BBYoda, Beez3, benggie, blitzxgene, bobie306, caesar, catmoon10000, Chrismannix, chronomac, Cirus, claptonish, cmanlee, cminervi22, codestothestars, Creative Username, customcarvin, Danster5, Dark67790, datrumole, DaveRose, ddss, DemasteredDonkey, dep, dizzy_dan, drevored, elvin, EnZeeO, Ernesto, Exxon, f0elet, faelgrim, FanEditViewer, Fedekin605, felixking, flarecrow, frienca, GaldorCID, Gamgise, Gegabone, Gioxtream, goldberryndahood, gotosat582, Gromance, h_thomspon, HereticGrin, hojlunder, hordo89, iamcolin, InGensaurus, JacobK, javiba04, jerkbait_swe, joanriera99, JohnGrey, Johnsmith17, joker555, jskywalker001, jumbeeman, kala005, Katemaru, Kestun, kodakev, kuddlesworth9419, Kuzan Madero, LaserPrinterBW, lightkiller100, lithium, livingnexus, loadingx86, LoonDawg, lordasriel, lotr_fan, LOTRfan, lovegamegie, lubi0019, luciminate, luhcka, Luthien telperien, M0053DR00L, madsheep, maevie, magnitood, malink, Mans550, marquitox, Mat0u5, McConnor, me_a_ri, Melobiotic88, mike2801.lee, Minchillanca, misterguy, Miwan23, mmctid, morfin, murciero, MVP, nathaniel03, NeedLink, Nick66, nickbond, Nickolas Olsen, nightstalkerpoet, Nikopold, OneRing56, Onhisbacko, OrangeGeemer, Partyprime, patrickmollohan, pepcisko, pheanor, picard68, Poker, PopTart, PuffyRainbowCloud, Pyramas, QuantumMecha, qwertzqwertz123, randomlotrfan88, RAPSRL, reality4u, ribx, roachfire, rovanian, runetunes, scaredycat, scottbot34, SF, sfury, shaolin95, shoquillis, SilverFlare, spliff_tennen, Spunjeroo, SquirrelTail, Stelitu, Stereogram, Subwai, sunsetvegas, syardumi, TerryWan-Kenobi0369, testa6421, thepoynt, thesoundofbob, theycallmehammi, tholdrath, TineyTurtle, TinOwl, tjd32, TopperHarley104, torovar, tpooz, Trespatitos, Triggeh, trmv, Trystero, umaximus, unix5, Untitled, vdeckerx, velsuz, venasque, Vic, Vvd97, w0odyallen, warchilde30, WaterOverlord, Wizhein, wjm110, xpanmanx, yeknom02, YevX

PM’d links to all Theatrical 4K Dremastered.

Just want to note that DrDre hasn’t been active for a while now because of other focus (check their profile). I believe they will return and finish some of the remasters, especially the FOTR Extended 4K Dremastered Part 2.

Until then, cheers!

Mat0u5 said:

Hmm, just something i found interesting:
Here is a comparison between the 4K Dremastered edition and the normal Extended Edition (with the green tint) showing one of the Galadriel scenes in Lothlórien:
https://i.postimg.cc/gJbBK3rX/dremastered-comparison.png

Honestly, i like the extended edition better (only for this scene and a couple others tho, i do genuinely admire this project). But in the extended edition, Galadriel is just so much more detailed compared to the Dremastered version - i mean, its not even close.

I get that Lothlórien is SUPPOSED to look more “ethereal” in the Dremastered version - and it DOES, with the white lighting and all, it DOES look more ethereal. But i also think that the white lighting is so strong, that it drowns some of the details (or thats my reasoning anyway, i dont know the real explonation).
And this specific example is just waaaay too blurry for my taste on the Dremastered version.

From what I read, the original theatrical and extended versions have their fare share of detail/clarity in certain scenes. E.g. a scene is much more detailed in theatrical, but no on the extended. In another scene, the extended is more detailed than theatrical. Something to do with post-processing the different versions, correct me if I’m wrong anyone. The Dremastered version is a 4K upscaled and color-graded of the 1080p theatrical release. It would be quite a project to select and cut the detailed scenes from the extended version. Maybe we’ll get one one day.

amaguma_kun,cmanlee,dep,dizzy_dan,Exxon,frienca,Gio,iamcolin,LOTRfan,Mat0u5,McConnor,MVP,Nikopold,ribx,Triggeh,umaximus

PM’d

samwisethe_brave_, Mithreindeer

PM’d

NeatoUmbra, ruster, johnny95art, tnarg, antynus, sid8530, jlef77, Ratking, kimbo, alcappuccino, Mimendra, VaterYester, greven, Alpadow, DarkLord77, THEDARKKNIGHT88, playbedar, Snyer, snorp, manuman888, steezystan, luvplayn, toxicfella, bearcake103, niborc, superJ, samwise2204, jhl2859, flor podesta, rxsiu, Burrito, GoldWallaby, TomBrun1, Angel100, ender17, Roothar, wcaniell, Kaileth19, Sonicwithashotgun, khasanovabror, papasirow, RevSC, gotosat582, IvoryOak, yankyfan09, lockgrid, oswaldo, bowlofspiders, Crustacean, lreek, MegaMind007, milquetoast, Derdiedas21345, mugmealer, ToxicHeadshot, withbirds, dwarferagon, dandalftheblu, Al2501, CriterionX, snotovitz, evestorm, jozymandias, illuvatar, atnahom, Esan, mattjames355, frankyvalentino, klask, navieko, RyanGreen23, AWS-77, dogesatiric, romanes_eunt_domus, harlekin, remsouille, WoCool

PM’d

May I have the link for this? Thank you in advance!

I was able to grab the 4K 35mm FOTR theatrical so far. Here are some screenshot comparisons between the 35mm and Blu-ray theatricals: https://imgur.com/a/zEEoWR6

In my opinion, I love the colors and gritty feel (noise) of the 35mm. However, I feel there are some loss in details, especially in the black crush areas. You can see that in some brighter scenes, the details are better than the Blu-ray theatricals, like more depth in the grass or buildings. It’s hard for me, I like both, can’t decide between the two. I guess, it depends on the mood.

I am not sure if this is intentional, but here’s the difference between Dremastered extended vs. theatrical for those curious: https://imgur.com/a/Vhr46oG