logo Sign In

frater

User Group
Members
Join date
16-Aug-2024
Last activity
24-Aug-2024
Posts
3

Post History

Post
#1603982
Topic
Project Threepio (Star Wars OOT subtitles)
Time

DVD-BOY said:

I think Frater may have been saying the Dutch subtitles used ‘O’, and like English, modern Dutch also uses ‘Oh’.

That was how I interpreted his comment.

Yes, that’s correct.
In 3PO’s Dutch subtitles “O” is used instead of “Oh”.

When I wrote it I actually thought it was done in the English one as well, but I just checked and it isn’t the case.
I must have had another subtitle at hand.
I also quickly checked the German one. That one too has the, IMHO, correct “Oh”.

So, it’s only the Dutch subtitle that could have an improved “Oh”. 😉

Post
#1603801
Topic
Project Threepio (Star Wars OOT subtitles)
Time

Hi Catbus,

Thank you very much.

I just received the subtitles and I was wondering if you agree that it would be a good thing to (also) distribute them as MKV files.
Within an MKV you can give the files attributes (original language, commentary, SDH, Forced), set the order and give them names.

Maybe this has been proposed before, I don’t know.
It’s merely a suggestion.

Oh, and another thing.
Maybe it’s only me, but personally I prefer to use ‘Oh’ instead of ‘O’.
I’ve asked ChatGPT what it has documented and it came with this.
I’m not saying that ChatGPT is always right, but it does agree with how I felt about it:

"Use of “Oh” vs. “O” in English:
“Oh”:

“Oh” is the more common form in modern English and is used to express emotion, surprise, recognition, or other spontaneous reactions.
Examples: “Oh, I didn’t know that!” or “Oh, now I understand.”
It’s frequently used in everyday conversation and informal writing.
“O”:

“O” is typically associated with poetry, liturgy, and elevated or solemn language. It often appears in classical literature, hymns, and sometimes in formal speeches.
Examples: “O Romeo, Romeo! Wherefore art thou Romeo?” (from Shakespeare) or “O Lord, hear my prayer.”
It has an archaic or literary connotation and is less commonly used in modern, everyday language.
Consensus and Guidelines:

In English, as in Dutch, there is no strict rule dictating which form is more correct; the choice between “Oh” and “O” depends on the tone, style, and context. “Oh” is much more common in contemporary usage, while “O” is often reserved for specific styles or more formal registers.

If you’re writing in a modern, informal context, “Oh” is usually the appropriate choice. However, in literary or formal contexts, “O” might be more fitting. Your preference for “Oh” aligns well with modern language use."